65 Fans Tested on a Megahalems

This project began with a goal — run an Intel Core i7 860 at 4GHz consistently in a room with ambient temperatures of thirty degrees centigrade (30°C), and without excessive noise. Among the air-cooled heatsinks, the Prolimatech Megahalems Rev. B seemed to be the best choice at the time. The Megahalems Rev. B also comes with clips for two 120×25 mm fans, and clips for 120×38 mm fans are available, from other retailers. The Megahalems does not come with its own fans. This avoids wasting money on fans that may not meet the user’s needs, but it does raise the question, “What fans do I use?” I have collected a number of fans from a variety of places; they run from fancy to plain, expensive to dirt cheap, noisy to barely audible. I tested all of these on the Megahalems heatsink.

Test Setup

  • CPU: Intel Core i7 860 @ 4 GHz (22×182 MHz) with Hyper-Threading
  • Vcore: Set to 1.31250 V, but ran at 1.312 – 1.328 V
  • Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-P55A-UD3P
  • Memory: 2×2 GB G.Skill Ripjaws DDR3-2000 (9-9-9-27)
  • SSD: 64 GB Kingston SSDNow V+ Series
  • OS: Microsoft Windows 7 64-bit
  • CPU Heatsink: Prolimatech Megahalems
  • TIM: Gelid Solutions GC3 Extreme
  • Sound Pressure Level (SPL) Meter: Tenma 72-942
  • Stress Test: OCCT/Linpack

Methodology

After a number of OCCT test runs, the system comes to equilibrium after about 35 minutes, and no further information was gained beyond 40 minutes. After that, CPU temperature changes reflected changes in the ambient temperature. So, the fan runs were 40 minutes each.

CPU temperatures were based on the temperature signal sent by the CPU itself and interpreted by OCCT (it does not  correspond with the actual temperature, but it is close enough for our purposes). Because the CPU reports the temperature in one degree Celsius (1 °C) increments, it was unable to report a temperature between those increments. However, a common pattern in temperature traces was a rapid alternation between a temperature and a temperature one degree higher. When a temperature reading fluctuated between one level and another, it was recorded as the lower temperature plus 0.5°C.

Ambient temperatures were taken with a digital thermometer and reported to the nearest half a degree Celsius (0.5 °C). These were subtracted from the CPU temps to give temperature over ambient. This allows for results made at different times with different ambient temperatures to be compared. The more powerful the fan, the lower the temperature over ambient. Various specifications of fan output such as RPM, Static Pressure and CFM are merely suggestive. The temperature over ambient measurement is the final result.

Sound pressure is measured in decibels, abbreviated as dB. The standard weighting is type A, abbreviated dBA. The SPL meter reports sound pressure levels (SPL) in tenths of a decibel. However, the meter specifications say it is accurate to 0.5 decibel above 30 dBA, so in the tables the SPL values were reported in 0.5 dB increments. When there is no extraneous noise, the basement where the fans were tested has a SPL of under 10 dBA, so background noise did not interfere with SPL measurements. The SPL measurements were made at 10 cm and converted to the standard 1 meter equivalent by subtracting 20 dB. Because a fan is loudest at its face, the reported SPL is 10 cm from the fan intake face. Note that your setup will have its own acoustics, so the noise at 10 cm may not drop off as rapidly as theory says; but these measurements are designed to allow us to compare fans, so they were converted to the standard measure: one meter (1 m).

The thermal interface material chosen was one of the top performers in a recent 80-way TIM review. After trying several TIM, I settled on this one because I get the most consistent results with it. After the heatsink was mounted, the system was not disturbed at all for the length of the testing. Because even a fast-setting TIM like GC3 Extreme gains in performance over the first few days of its placement, formal fan testing did not begin until the fourth day. The entire set of tests was done over a 19 day span in April 2010. Following the testing, the heatsink was dismounted and the TIM pattern examined. The center of the CPU heat spreader showed near-exclusion of the TIM, with an even pattern of TIM surrounding the center.

The Fans

Below is the list of fans tested, as used on the chart (in parentheses: blade count, fan size, airflow in cubic feet per minute – CFM – reported by manufacturer, and other information as appropriate; ‘N/A’ means ‘not available’):

120×25 mm fans:Akasa Apache (PWM, 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 57.53 CFM)
Antec TriCool L (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, low setting, 39 CFM)
Antec TriCool M (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, medium setting, 56 CFM)
Antec TriCool H (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, high setting, 79 CFM)
Arctic Cooling 12L (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 37 CFM)
Bulk generic (from geeks.com, unbranded 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
CM BladeMaster (Cooler Master PWM, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 21.2 – 76.8 CFM)
CM R4 (Cooler Master R4-L2R-20AC-GP, 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 69 CFM)
Coolink SWiF2 (SWiF2-1201, 11-bladed, 120×25 mm, 55.44 CFM)
Delta WFB1212H (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 86.50 CFM)
Enermax Cluster (PWM, 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 23.86 to 53.02 CFM)
Enermax Magma (9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 69.15 CFM)
FDB-12-1300 (Thermalright 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 50.0 CFM)
FN-121 (Silverstone 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 53.24 CFM)
Gelid S12 (Gelid Solutions 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 37 CFM)
GT-1150 (Scythe/Nidec-Servo 9-bladed Gentle Typhoon, 120×25 mm, 37.1 CFM)
GT-1450 (Scythe/Nidec-Servo 9-bladed Gentle Typhoon, 120×25 mm, 45.9 CFM)
GT-1850 (Scythe/Nidec-Servo 9-bladed Gentle Typhoon, 120×25 mm, 58.3 CFM)
Magma + Cluster (Enermax 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
MassCool FD12025 (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 52.05 CFM)
MechaTronics 120 mm (MXA1225L12D FSR, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
Nexus Real Silent (D12SL-12, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 36.87 CFM)
Noctua NF-P12 (9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 54.3 CFM)
Noctua NF-S12B (7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 59.2 CFM)
Noctua P12 + S12B (120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
NZXT (DF1202512RFLN, 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 47 CFM)
OKGear 2wire (1710 rpm, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
OKGear 3wire (1525 rpm, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)
Papst 25 mm (4412FML, 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 67.1 CFM)
Papst 32 mm (4312 MS, 5-bladed, 120×32 mm, 82.4 CFM)
RFA-120BL (Rosewill 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 74.48 CFM)
RFX-120BL (Rosewill 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 43.5 – 87.5 CFM)
SA-9G1212P4G03 (Sanyo Denki PWM 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 32 to 130 CFM)
SA-9S1212F401 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 70.6 CFM)
SA-9S1212H401 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 86.51 CFM)
SA-9S1212L401 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 48.1 CFM)
Scythe generic (AD1212DS-A73GL(6TCL3), 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 46 CFM)
S-FLEX 1200 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 49.0 CFM)
S-FLEX 1600 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 63.7 CFM)
S-FLEX 1900 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 75.0 CFM)
SlipStream1200 (Scythe 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 68.54 CFM)
SlipStream1600 (Scythe 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 88.11 CFM)
SlipStream1900 #1 (Scythe 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 110.31 CFM)
SlipStream1900 #2 (Scythe 9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 110.31 CFM)
TT-A2018 (Thermaltake 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 38.6 to 93.7 CFM)
YL D12SH-12 (Yate Loon 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 88 CFM)
YL D12SL-12 (Yate Loon 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 47 CFM)
YL D12SL-12 LED (Yate Loon 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, 47 CFM)
ZM-F3 (Zalman 7-bladed, 120×25 mm, CFM N/A)

120×38 mm fans:

Centaur (Japan Servo CNDC12Z7RP, 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 124 CFM)
EBM 38 mm (EBM Papst W2G110-AF45-19, 5-bladed, 120×38 mm, 105.9 CFM)
MechaTronics 38mm (MD1238H12B, 9-bladed fan with 13 vanes to direct airflow, 120×38 mm, 174 CFM)
NMB Panaflo Med (FBA12G12M-1BX, 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 86.5 CFM)
SA-9G1212E1011 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 118 CFM)
SA-9G1212G101 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 137 CFM)
SA-9G1212H101 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 99 CFM)
SA-9G1212M101 (Sanyo Denki 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 74 CFM)
Servo Centaur (Japan Servo CNDC12Z7RP, 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 124 CFM)
Servo Round (Japan Servo SCNDM12B4, 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 106 CFM)
Ultra Kaze 1000 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 44.44 CFM)
Ultra Kaze 2000 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 87.63 CFM)
Ultra Kaze 3000 (Scythe 7-bladed, 120×38 mm, 133.60 CFM)

140×25 mm fans:

Evercool RSF-14 (11-bladed, 140×25 mm, CFM N/A)
Kaze Maru 1200 (Scythe 11-bladed, 140×25 mm, 61.30 CFM)
Kaze Maru 1900 (Scythe 11-bladed, 140×25 mm, 104.54 CFM)
Kaze Maru 2 1700 (Scythe 9-bladed, 140×25 mm, 92.4 CFM)
MassCool FD14025 (7-bladed, 140×25 mm, 27.2 to 47.8 CFM)
Noctua NF-P14 (9-bladed, 120×25 mm, 64.9 CFM)
X-Silent 140 (Thermalright 11-bladed, 140×25 mm, 60.42 CFM)
YL D14SH-12 (Yate Loon 7-bladed, 140×25 mm, 140 CFM)
YL D14SM-12 (Yate Loon 7-bladed, 140×25 mm, 62 CFM)

Results

The following charts show the CPU temperatures of the hottest core at the end of 40 minutes, for each fan or set of fans. Each chart starts with the highest performing fans, and ends with fans that allowed the CPU core temp to reach 80°C – the fans that failed my criteria.

To figure out what your own temperatures might be if you ran the same system of components, add the Temp Over Ambient to your own ambient temperature. That will give you some notion of what to expect. These charts are here to show the relative cooling performance and noise between each fan. Remember, the goal is to have a CPU core temp no higher than 80 °C with an ambient of 30 °C. In other words, I need a temp over ambient of 50 °C or less. Very few fans were that good.

Note:  Three separate images make up this chart.

Nine of the top ten fans in cooling performance were 120×38 mm fans. These fans have excellent airflow, and tend to have higher static pressure than 120×25 mm fans. But, you pay for this performance with more noise. Of these fans, the San Ace 9G1212H101/9G1212H1011 is the fan with best cooling and least noise. But at over $18 per fan, it is fairly expensive. The Scythe Ultra Kaze performed as well, but was somewhat louder; it sounds louder than the SPL measurement. The main advantage is cost: you can buy one in the US for under $9. But it is a sleeve bearing fan. You must lubricate the bearing periodically to keep it running well. The Servo Centaur and Servo Round are excess inventory fans available for less than $6. They are fairly noisy, but high quality ball bearing fans. The NMB “Panaflo” Medium “hydro wave bearing”  fan is widely available, with prices starting under $13. Based on the performance of the Medium, you should expect a Panaflo High to cool about as well as a San Ace, but 5 decibels louder. All of these fans make a clicking sound when they are undervolted – run at less than 12 volts. But the San Ace and NMB Panaflo fans have much quieter clicking; you may not even hear them click.

Probably the best balance of cooling power and noise in a single 120×25 mm fan is the Cooler Master Blade Master. Widely available, the lowest price I have seen is $13 shipped. Following closely behind, though a bit noisier, is the Yate Loon D12SH-12 fan. There are reviewers who swear by this fan, and it can be found for $3.70 apiece, or $3.33 each for three or more. Another 120×25 mm fan that performs well is the 1900 rpm Scythe Slip Stream, available for $6. All three of these are sleeve bearing fans. They also click very quietly when undervolted.

The Gentle Typhoons and the San Ace Silent series – 9S1212H401, 9S1212F401 and 9S1212L401 – have no clicking when undervolted. These are all ball bearing fans. The Gentle Typhoons are available for under $13, but the San Ace Silents are over $22 apiece, or over 23 English pounds in the UK. The bargain ball bearing fan is the Rosewill RFX-120. It comes bundled with a slot type fan controller, and seems not to click when undervolted.

Finally, the Cooler Master R4-L2R-20AC-GP and the Zalman ZM-F3 are available for under $10, sometimes significantly less. Both are pretty well-performing sleeve bearing fans.

The rest of the fans – including the 140 mm fans – will make nice case fans. The Sound Pressure Level readings and their cooling performances will give you some notion of how well these fans will work as case fans.

I tested some fans in pairs. With the high performance fans, you get an extra degree of cooling for a lot more noise. With the better 120×25 mm fans, though, the results were more interesting. Those YL D12SH-12′s really shine here. The CM R4′s and Blade Masters look nice, as do the pairs of Slip Stream fans. By the way – the 1600 RPM and 1200 RPM Slip Streams sound a lot quieter than their SPL measurements. I think the SPL meter picks up the white noise that our ears just ignore.

Conclusion

So, what’s the best fan for your Megahalems? The San Ace 9G1212H101/9G1212H1011 is the fan that meets the 50 °C temperature over ambient criterion with the least noise. For a pair of fans, the Yate Loon D12SH-12 comes closest with a temp over ambient of 50.5 °C without being too loud, but in general two fans make a lot more noise for only a little more cooling. It is clear that we must accept a trade-off between fan cooling power and fan noise. As usual with overclocking, there are no simple decisions.

-ehume

Tags: , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>