Features


Overclockers Forum

Shopping Search



Top Products


Motherboards

Intel

Abit

Gigabyte

Asus

EPoX

Iwill

MSI

Shuttle

Tyan

Soyo


Processors

AMD

Intel

Compaq


Cases

Antec

ATX

Enlight


Graphic Cards

Leadtek

ATI

Creative Labs

Hercules

MSI

VisionTek

nVidia


Memory

SDRAM

RDRAM

DDRAM

DDR


Sound Cards

Creative Labs

Jaton

SIIG

SB Live

Guillemot


Hard Drives

Fujitsu

IBM

Maxtor

Quantum


Networking

Linksys Lan Cards

Ethernet Cards

FDDI Cards

Networking Kits


Misc.

Monitors

CD Roms/Burners

Printers

Scanners

Software

REVIEWS & TIPS
Over 1000 Topics

ACCESSORIES
ADAPTERS
BEGINNER GUIDES
BENCHMARKING
BIOS
BUYING ADVICE
BX COOLER
CASE COOLING
CASE REVIEWS
CONTESTS
CONTROLLERS
CPU REVIEWS AND TIPS
HARD DRIVES
HEATSINK REVWS AND TIPS
HUMAN INTEREST
MEMORY MISCELLANEOUS
MOTHERBOARD REVIEWS
OVERCLOCKING EXPERIENCES AND TIPS
PELTIERS
PROBLEM PRODUCTS
REPAIRS
SYSTEM COOLERS
SYSTEM REVIEWS
THERMAL GREASE
UTILITIES
VENDOR REVIEWS
VIDEO CARD COOLING AND PERFORMANCE
VIDEO CARD REVIEWS
WATER COOLING


Please read EMAIL FAQs first: Comments, suggestions, and questions to Joe Citarella, Skip MacWilliam, or Ed Stroligo

"King Flowmeter"
Joe Citarella - 5/22/03


SUMMARY: Adding tubing runs and watercooling components can substantially impact waterpump flowrates.

Flowmeter

One of the pieces of test gear to measure waterblock performance is a liquid flowmeter - this measures flow through a system, in this case, in gallons per minute (gpm). The flowmeter I bought is made by King Instruments¹ and measures flows from 0 to 3 gpm - just the range I'm interested in.

This is an analog instrument that basically is a tapered tube with a stainless steel float that is pushed up by water pressure - the more pressure, the higher the gpm - simple concept, lots or precision manufacturing to do it accurately. The stainless steel float

Read

looks like a mushroom. Once it stabilizes, you read the gpm off the sight glass. I found it quite easy and use a ruler for reading between the markings on the scale.

To give an example of what I can use this for, I tried a number of waterpumps to familiarize myself with using it. What follows is what I found for an EHEIM 1250 waterpump using combinations of tubing size, radiator, CPU and GPU waterblocks (just measuring flow - not pressure).

Set

Note the GPU waterblock uses a "swirl" design.

The EHEIM 1250 is rated for 317 gph, or 5.28 gpm, with a delivery head of 6'7". It features a ¾" intake and ½" on the output side. As soon as you hook up hoses etc., flow rates² drop quickly:

Flow Test Measurements - EHEIM 1250

Setup
GPM
% of Spec
Spec Rating
5.28
100%
1/2" Tubing
2.62
49.6%
3/8" Tubing
2.04
38.6%
Waterblock Alone
1.54
29.1%
Radiator Alone
1.35
25.6%
GPU Waterblock Alone
0.81
15.3%
WB + Rad
1.13
21.4%
WB + Rad + Gpu
0.67
12.7%

Note: 3/8" tubing was used with radiator and waterblocks, which feature 3/8" nipples.

Obviously this is only for this setup and does not address pressure, but I think it's representative of typical watercooling systems many of our readers are using. Whatever waterpump you have, figure at a minimum actual waterflow through your system is something like 15 - 30% of the pump's rating with just a radiator and waterblock.

The more that's included in the cooling loop, including GPU waterblocks and 90 degree bends, the more it reduces waterflow. In addition, the smaller the tubing diameter, the lower the flow. Waterblocks, GPUs and radiators with anything below 3/8" fittings are not conducive to high flow rates.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, the larger the diameter, the better. However, I feel that anything over 1/2" tubing is difficult to work and fit, but anything below 3/8" ID will severely compromise flow rates. Placing a small diameter GPU in a large diameter cooling loop will slow things down appreciably.

¹King Instrument Company - Stainless Steel, Liquid Flowmeter. It has 1" Female NPT connections, both in and out, and has viewing windows on two sides. The overall length is 19-1/2" long, with the flowtube box, 14-1/2" long x 4-1/2" square. The viewing windows are 2-1/2" x 11", and the scale for the flowmeter, is 0-3.0 GPM, marked in 0.05 GPM divisions. The float is # 3/4-GPV-S2 for a liquid with a specific gravity of 1.0 (water).

²I should also note that the instrument itself will impact flow rates (5" H2O).

Email Joe


<< back to home