"Swiftech MCW50-T GPU Waterblock"
Joe Citarella - 3/11/04
page 3
Using a TEC
Effectively using a TEC involves more than simply slapping one on and running it. I strongly advise anyone interested in using this product to carefully read all the items HERE. In particular, Swiftech notes that:
- "The combined amount of heat (TEC + GPU) added to the circuit by the MCW50-T is approximately 115 watts (392 BTU/hr).
- The thermoeletric module pulls approximately 6A at 12 volts. When connecting the MCW50-T module to an existing power supply, users should verify their power supply current rating for the +12 volts line.
- [The MCW50-T] will dissipate 53 Watts continuous thermal load to ambient temperature."
As I tested this unit, I noted that the heat load was considerably higher and I had to cool much more aggressively than for a waterblock without a TEC (no surprise). I also tested with a separate 12 volt power supply - a practice I highly recommend when using a TEC in any system.
I also want to point out that the load you can place on any TEC is limited. If you exceed its capacity, you will find that the TEC will run wild; that is, temps will continue to increase in a destructive heat loop. A safe, conservative operating guidline is to not exceed 50% of the TEC's rating - in this case, 40 watts. In this instance, once I went over 50 watts, I started to see temps continue to creep up. At 70 watts, it started to get scary.
THE TEST
The Swiftech MCW50-T was tested using the CPU Die Simulator and Waterblock Test Rig. In this case, I will not report a C/W as it has no meaning when using a TEC, but show the delta T I achieved at 40 and 50 watts.
WATERBLOCK TEST RESULTS
Test Conditions: Inlet Water Temp: 28.5 C; Mounting force: 15 pounds.
| Waterblock @ watts, gpm |
Die Temp Diff to Water |
| Swiftech MCW50-T @ 40 watts, 1 gpm |
-8.1 C |
| Swiftech MCW50-T @ 50 watts, 1 gpm |
1.6 C |
| Swiftech MCW50-T @ 50 watts, 1.5 gpm |
-2.8 C |
It was interesting to see the increase in performance by increasing waterflow through the waterblock; high efficiencies are key to extracting maximum performance.
CONCLUSIONS
Swiftech's MCW50-T Waterblock is a fine choice for very aggressive GPU cooling, but I caution that TECs are tricky animals to tame. As GPU waterblocks are usually fitted in series with a CPU waterblock, in this case low flow resistance is VERY important; maximum performance may require a separate cooling loop.
Thanks again to Swiftech for sending this our way.
Email Joe