If one stick of corsair didn't run good with my NF7-S, will another?

I had a stick of Corsair XMS PC3200 that didn't run good with my NF7-S, couldn't even get to 200 Mhz. Right now I'm running kingston valueram, its working great. My question is, I want to add another 512mb stick of RAM and I got a good deal on some PC3200 Corsair value select memory. Do you think it will run ok, or will it be like the last corsair?

Well, I just ordered...hopefully it'll be ok