Figured out a way to make it work.
Rules I put in, in the correct order:
1) Basically says "If incoming message is not sent to ME, delete it"
I found this has gotten rid of about 95%, or more, of the spam that was on this old email account of mine. Most of the either don't have the email sent to my email address, not sure how I still received them but whatever.
2) To help me sort out any junk I may have left over, the second rule says
"Move all messages from people on my contact list to the folder 'Other Inbox' "
So anyone that is not on my contacts list will go to my normal inbox folder, and I can check to see if I want to put that person on my contacts list or delete them or whatever later. All my family and what not goes to my other folder now.
Noone probably cares about these but figured I'd post an answer to my own question anyways. =P
