TV Tuner Image quality question

[ARCJr]

Which has a better analog picture quality, the Hauppauge PVR-150 or the ATI HDTV Wonder? Unfortunately, I need to remove one of them from my system and I'm trying to figure out whether the difference in analog picture quality (which a lot of my recordings are) is worth the loss of an HDTV tuner. I'll be getting a VBox PCI-E HD card, so I won't be losing HD capability entirely. Thanks in advance.

[Jon]

Well, I'm a firm believer in picture quality being relative, to an extent. Have you recorded analog with both? What do you think?

All I'm saying is that we're not the ones watching what you record. Whichever looks best to you is the one you should stick with.

[ARCJr]

No, I've never used the analog side of the HDTV Wonder.