PDA

View Full Version : PAL 8045: XP1800 at 43c idle


BuckShot1969
01-24-02, 02:35 PM
Based on what I've read, I should be in the mid 30's with this heat sink (4000rpm Delta). It's running on a KR7ARAID in a full inwin tower with the enermax 431 (two fans). I have one intake 80mmm and 2 pulling out from the back. I used ASII very thin layer, but didn't rub it on, wipe it off, rub it on, wipe it off, rub it, wipe it, rub, wipe, and rub some more. I just put a thin layer and installed the heatsink. My box temp is at 32c with two round cables, and 2 flat using 4 separate IDE channels. Geforce3 on the agp, a NIC, firewire, and sound on the PCI's. I'm using the Winbond Hardware Doctor to monitor. I don't go above 47c at full load. AND.....this is not overclocked. Can't get above 143 FSB without WinXP Pro getting qwerky. Any thoughts?

Sonny
01-24-02, 02:47 PM
1. What are your ambient temps?

2. Halt-On-Idle?

3. Is the HSF on tight enough? You need more washers for the springs.

4. What happens when you take the panels off?

5. Bad application of thermal compound.

BuckShot1969
01-24-02, 02:55 PM
system is at 32c...room temps in the neighborhood of 72 f on average. Cooler at night and the temps do drop to 39c idle. Not sure what you mean "halt on idle". The heatsink is screwed all the way down according to the instructions. Springs are at full compression. My guess is the system temp is too high and there is a proportional relationship to system and cpu temps. Am I right?

UserName
01-24-02, 02:58 PM
flip the two back fans over to blow in and flip the front over to blow out and you will lose 3C.

Sonny
01-24-02, 03:37 PM
Originally posted by BuckShot1969
system is at 32c...room temps in the neighborhood of 72 f on average. Cooler at night and the temps do drop to 39c idle. Not sure what you mean "halt on idle". The heatsink is screwed all the way down according to the instructions. Springs are at full compression. My guess is the system temp is too high and there is a proportional relationship to system and cpu temps. Am I right? Yup! I shouldve realized that with a small variation in temp readings from idle to load the HSF mustve been mounted properly but it never hurts to check. I get low idle temps because I have enabled the Halt-On-Idle command for my CPU, what it does basically is to minimize the voltage feed on the CPU during idle state only but load temps will not change. Maybe better airflow thru your case would net you a cooler running system.

DodgeViper
01-24-02, 08:06 PM
Your ambient temps are to high. If the ambient temp within your home is 72 degree's then the air flow through your case is not working for you. Your case temps should be around 24c. Typically when air cooling your CPU should be 10-14c above the case temps. This is depending on the heatsink and fan combination. I have the same H/S and I lapped the the H/S. Curently my case/cpu temps are 24c/38c. Once you get more air moving from front to back you will see the case/cpu temps drop.

MadMan007
01-25-02, 04:00 AM
Yeah, dodge is right. I mean, only one intake fan? Personally I prefer to set up cases with a bit more intake than out. Keeps the case temps closer to ambient. But you NEED to get at least one more intake, or a stronger intake fan. Also, what CFM is that fan on your HS? You might have slightly higher temps if other people are using the 68CFM model...

BuckShot1969
01-25-02, 08:43 AM
I've got a 46.1 cfm Delta on the cpu. The case fans are your run of the mill variety. All 80mm though. I guess I could mod another fan on the intake and replace the existing intake. I bet it doesn't turn more than 3000rpm. The air coming out of the rear fans doesn't seem that hot. I wonder of the temp readings are accurate....anyone read anything about the KR7A giving false readings? I know ASUS's board has issues.

Big Mike
01-25-02, 10:19 AM
When you say the springs are compressed, did you use one washer above and one below the spring? despite the fact that it seems to be ok many have found that you should skip straight to using 1 above and 2 at the bottom per the instructions where it talks about if its not cooling well enough. Id suggest you do this, also if you lose some washers like i did Lowe's carrys metric nylon washers, i think they were 6's or 8s, just take one with you and match it up, a bag of four is like 50 cents.

DodgeViper
01-25-02, 10:44 AM
BuckShot, is the CPU fan blowing onto the H/S? Once you improve the case temps your CPU temps will follow. I place three washers on top and one below the spring and drop my temps 2c. But be VERY carefull not to over stress the chip with to much pressure (spring load).

BuckShot1969
01-25-02, 02:39 PM
Should have said in the last post. The fan is blowing away from the cpu. I don't know if I follow the logic on adding more washers. That doesn't really tighten any more or less which is controlled by how much torque I put on the screws. It's on pretty tight. I wouldn't want to tighten it any more that's for sure. I think if I add more case fans, improve the flow of air through the case, and if you suggest turning the cpu fan to blow ONTO the cpu instead of AWAY, let me know. Thanks for everyone's input....

AntiHeiss
01-25-02, 02:56 PM
Definately turn the fan to blow into the HSF it will cool it much much better. And as for your ambient temps you should probably get another fan. If nothing else you may want to try switching your intake fan with the higher CFM on your HSF and put the lower CFM fan on your HSF. I had a friend do this and it was actually more effective. But first of all...turn that fan on the HSF and see what happens....Good luck.

DodgeViper
01-25-02, 03:54 PM
You have got to rotate that H/S fan. You want it blowing onto the H/S. You will see an improvement, but you have to increase the front to back case flow to lower the ambient temps. Good Luck.

BuckShot1969
01-25-02, 05:40 PM
Ok, flipped the Delta cpu fan to blow ONTO the cpu. I'm running 42c now where as I was getting lower before, although my ambient temp went up to 32c. That's over 100f which is a far cry from the 73-75f max that is in my office. It's been warm in Atlanta the past few weeks so the house has been heating up and no airconditioning. Anyone have a good proportion for room temp and ambient system temp? I need to read back through the posts, someone may have put that in there. I think someone said I should get below 27c on the system temp.

Sonny
01-25-02, 06:01 PM
It's nice if you can get your system temp around 27°C but if your ambient temps are higher than that your going to need active cooling to get below it. I think that your doing ok with what you have BUT do try to get an equal amount of CFM going in & out of your case & don't forget to factor in the PSU's fans when you start to add more intake fans. The best thing to find the cooling potential of your system right now would be to take the panels of & use a house fan to blow fresh air into the case then run your system as hard as you can. Since your HSF is mounted properly this will give you a good idea of what o shoot for. Regarding the fans on your Alpha to either blow or suck the only way to find out which is better is when you have successfully taken care of your case flow issues then try it both ways. Alpha designs their HS to have the fans suck air off of it but you never really know untill you try which works best. Every configuration is unique:beer:Written by JoeC
Interpreting C/W: For every watt the CPU radiates, the heatsink will cool the core by the (C/W x watts) plus ambient temp. For example, at an ambient temp of 25 C, a C/W of 0.25 with a CPU radiating 50 watts means that the CPU core temp will be 50 x 0.25 = 12.5 C over ambient temp, or 37.5 C. The lower the C/W, the better.Use this formula to get an estimate of what your HSF can achieve. DO visit the MainPage of this site to get you C/W rating.

Crazy Jayhawk
01-25-02, 08:03 PM
Originally posted by AntiHeiss
Definately turn the fan to blow into the HSF it will cool it much much better.I also have an Alpha 8045.

My CPU temps went up several degrees when I turned the fan to blow toward the CPU.

Alpha's are designed to have the fan suck air off the heatsink.

paupton
01-25-02, 08:21 PM
Originally posted by BuckShot1969
Should have said in the last post. The fan is blowing away from the cpu. I don't know if I follow the logic on adding more washers. That doesn't really tighten any more or less which is controlled by how much torque I put on the screws. It's on pretty tight. I wouldn't want to tighten it any more that's for sure. I think if I add more case fans, improve the flow of air through the case, and if you suggest turning the cpu fan to blow ONTO the cpu instead of AWAY, let me know. Thanks for everyone's input....


You need to have the fan on the H/S blow toward the cpu not away from. You get more cooling effect than having the fan try to take hot air away from the H/S. This effect is multiplied if you provide better fresh cool air intake.

Crazy Jayhawk
01-25-02, 08:39 PM
Originally posted by paupton
You need to have the fan on the H/S blow toward the cpu not away from. You get more cooling effect than having the fan try to take hot air away from the H/S. This effect is multiplied if you provide better fresh cool air intake. Read above. Alpha heatsinks are designed to have the fan suck air off the CPU. They cool better and make less noise that way.

DodgeViper
01-25-02, 09:30 PM
Well I am going to have to eat my words. Crazy Jayhawk is correct. My temps improved when I rotated the fan to pull heat from the H/S. Below is my image with the fan blowing onto the H/S. I then will follow with the image showing the fan pulling the heat away from the H/S.

With having the fan pulling instead of blowing my case drop 1 degree and my CPU dropped 3 degrees.

Thanks Crazy Jayhawk, but Arizona Wildcats are better.

DodgeViper
01-25-02, 09:32 PM
Fan pulling heat from H/S.

Kendle666
01-25-02, 09:40 PM
Hmm...........the Alpha Pal 8045 is designed for the fan to blow away from the H/S and sucking air from arround the base of the Heatsink................that's what the shroud arround the H/S is for

DodgeViper
01-25-02, 10:23 PM
I wonder if you were to take aluminum tape and extend the shroud further down the heatsink, if this would help pull the heat out down near the cor.

Crazy Jayhawk
01-25-02, 10:43 PM
Originally posted by DodgeViper
Thanks Crazy Jayhawk, but Arizona Wildcats are better. Glad it worked for you.

Also, I'm not much of a sports fan. :p

BuckShot1969
01-26-02, 08:57 AM
A simple but EFFECTIVE method. I've got a 30,000mm fan blowing into the open case. Problems solved! I'm getting 24c system temps and 35c cpu temps. Now I only need to upgrade my sound card and speaker set up so I can hear what's going on with the computer. At least I found out what my BEST temps are and I might find that ducting air directly through the PC to the cpu will lower the cpu temps without having the open case with a house fan blowing on it. I think I can mount a 120mm fan on the front after cutting a few holes, duct that air through my 2 hard drives which are at opposite ends of the drive bays, which will go straight to the cpu. With 3 fans pulling air out, I would think that should be enough.

Any suggestions on 120mm fans?

DodgeViper
01-26-02, 09:49 AM
It's all about air flow. Try this site.

http://www.millisec.com/fans.html

This would be a good choice,

Panaflo 120x38 86.5CFM 3 pin(Low Noise)

Currently on my system I have positive pressure inside the case. I have 2-50 CFM pulling air into the case. In the rear I have 2-38 CFM pulling air from the case. My CPU is pulling the heat from the H/S using a 50 CFM fan. My P/S is also pulling from inside out.

crazyman
01-26-02, 10:10 AM
Originally posted by BuckShot1969
Based on what I've read, I should be in the mid 30's with this heat sink (4000rpm Delta). It's running on a KR7ARAID in a full inwin tower with the enermax 431 (two fans). I have one intake 80mmm and 2 pulling out from the back. I used ASII very thin layer, but didn't rub it on, wipe it off, rub it on, wipe it off, rub it, wipe it, rub, wipe, and rub some more. I just put a thin layer and installed the heatsink. My box temp is at 32c with two round cables, and 2 flat using 4 separate IDE channels. Geforce3 on the agp, a NIC, firewire, and sound on the PCI's. I'm using the Winbond Hardware Doctor to monitor. I don't go above 47c at full load. AND.....this is not overclocked. Can't get above 143 FSB without WinXP Pro getting qwerky. Any thoughts?

I have two 80mm intake in the front(down low) and two 80mm exhaust in the rear(up higher),these are all 4500rpm Sunon fans.
I think you might also want to look at your hsf,I have a Vantec cck-6035,it has a 7000 rpm delta,and my temps are descent.the hottest it gets is 35c after a round of unreal.and I live in southern california,my ambient temps are not extremely cold here,and I used Arctic Silverper this (http://www.arcticsilver.com/arctic_silver_instructions.htm)
this is idle>

DodgeViper
01-26-02, 10:25 AM
Crazyman, either you have your computer in a chilled room or you keep your home very cold. This would explain why your CPU & CASE temps are so low. If I were to open my back door and bring my ambient temps down I would get CASE temps that you have. I just can't convince my wife to keep the house temps in the sixties.

crazyman
01-26-02, 10:28 AM
Originally posted by DodgeViper
Crazyman, either you have your computer in a chilled room or you keep your home very cold. This would explain why your CPU & CASE temps are so low. If I were to open my back door and bring my ambient temps down I would get CPU temps that you have. I just can't convince my wife to keep the house temps in the sixties.

lol,,,it's in the 70's outside ,I don't know what the temp is inside here,this room is not too cold,I don't keep the heat on much,I don't know. :)

crazyman
01-26-02, 10:31 AM
here it is right now,you may be right,I think it's about in the mid 60's in here right now.

crazyman
01-26-02, 10:44 AM
Originally posted by DodgeViper
Crazyman, either you have your computer in a chilled room or you keep your home very cold. This would explain why your CPU & CASE temps are so low. If I were to open my back door and bring my ambient temps down I would get CPU temps that you have. I just can't convince my wife to keep the house temps in the sixties.

lol,, :( OH darnit,and I thought I was getting good temps because I did a good job setting up my new box!?!
:)

DodgeViper
01-26-02, 10:45 AM
No air driven fan system can cool below ambient air temps without some other means to cool the air. Your 7000-RPM Delta is where your gaining in the CPU temps though. This is why you have an 8c difference between the case and CPU temps.

I just not willing to have a computer sound like a vac.

crazyman
01-26-02, 10:52 AM
Originally posted by crazyman
here it is right now,you may be right,I think it's about in the mid 60's in here right now.

ok,so it's not THAT cold in my house then,look here (http://www.texloc.com/closet/cl_fah_cel_chart.html) that would be about 70 in my house. right? listen ,I am no expert on cooling,but I am learning here.thanks for the conversation,gotta go to work now(love my sat overtime),have a great day! :)
Dan

DodgeViper
01-26-02, 11:41 AM
Crazyman, you’re missing my point. I am not criticizing you or saying anything negative. Your temps that your getting is based on the ambient temps within your home.

To prove this point I opened my door to my computer room and allowed the fresh cool air from outside to cool my room. If you look above from my earlier posted images and the image below, you can see the effects the ambient temps within the environment of your computer room have on your CASE & CPU temps.

I was only able to pull this off as my wife is not home at the current time.

paupton
01-26-02, 10:18 PM
Originally posted by DodgeViper
No air driven fan system can cool below ambient air temps without some other means to cool the air. Your 7000-RPM Delta is where your gaining in the CPU temps though. This is why you have an 8c difference between the case and CPU temps.

I just not willing to have a computer sound like a vac.

GAWD can I say amen to that. I just pulled my delta 8000 rpm Model FFB0612EHE 51.cfm. I called it my vacuum fan. I did a decibel meter reading on it and guess WHUT....... 97-100 DECIBELS,,,,,, guys. That's ear splitting.
I have the side off right now and it is not unpleasant. Earlier today my computer was for sale. LOL not now though.