Eggsaver makes DealExtreme's shipping look decent by comparison. If I see something small that I want from Newegg and it includes Eggsaver, I'll pass and buy it on Amazon or eBay instead.
I'll still buy stuff like videocards and boards on Newegg as the prices are usually upwards of the best I can find and the layout makes it easy to find the features I want. I've started buying harddrives at the local TD stores though as they usually match or beat Newegg and returns are easy as there's no shipping involved. I would never buy anything from Tigerdirect's site though, as the one time I did (IP-phone) it actually took them 3 business days plus the weekend to process and ship the order.