Results 1 to 6 of 6
  1. #1
    New Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2012

    All in One vs Custom

    I was wondering should I go all in one, or a custom loop? I could easily build a loop and such... but that is more expensive and more work. The all in ones are cheaper and never have to be cleaned. Which leads me to a sub question... Why do they never have to be cleaned? Doesnt the metal inside oxidize? and algae grow?
    Ps, I am running a Q6600 currently but will probably upgrade to IB. And I have a 600t case, so space isnt an issue.

  2. #2
    Water Cooling Sticky Reading Enforcement Official
    m0r7if3r's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Marietta, GA
    Author Profile Heatware Profile
    The difference is performance. Anything that doesn't come presealed is immediately going to blow any of the LCLC units out of the water (within reason that is...)
    If years were seasons, this December would be the December of our December.
    -Abed #sixseasonsandamovie


  3. #3
    Senior Member rge's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    East Coast
    You could build a custom loop and run it with norprene tubing (just like sealed ones which dramatically decreases evaporation), and use corrosion inhibitors + biocide just as they do, and never clean it just as they dont. Or even with normal tubing and 150ml reservoir, it would take 5+ years before needing to add anything.

    And both your custom loop or the sealed all in one units will slowly get oxidized blocks, but the effect on the performance is less than 1C over couple years. But eventually some air will accumulate in rad, especially in factory sealed without reservoir but again performance wont take that much of a hit.

    It isnt that the factory sealed ones are going to last longer without cleaning if you build yours the same way, it is just the factory sealed ones accept the eventual small loss in performance and the internal build up of crud vs people that build theirs will simply clean it because they have higher standards and they can, especially when upgrading their equipment and the loop is broken down anyways.

    Water vapor transmission rates

    Tygon 3603 wvtr = 12.4 g*mil/100sq in/24hrs standard testing

    tygon b44-3 wvtr = 5.8 g*mil/100sq in/24hrs standard testing

    norprene 60 tubing = 1.1 g*mil/100sq in/24hrs standard testing

    So norprene is 6x less permeable to water vapor (6x less evaporation) than tygon plasticizer free beverage tubing 44-3 and 12x less permeable than tygon 3603. Also 1/8 inch wall tubing would half evaporation of 1/16 inch wall.
    Last edited by rge; 02-19-12 at 09:53 AM.
    5930K 4.5ghz, Koolance 380I wb
    MSI X99A Krait
    TitanX 1400mhz, EK wb
    360 + 280 rad for gpu/cpu
    Samsung 850 1 TB pro games, 500gb pro OS
    HyperX 3000C15
    Samsung 27 inch 1440
    EVGA G2 850

  4. #4
    New Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Well, it seems that I have gotten my answer. I am very particular about my computer and I am constantly doing stuff to it. So for me it looks like it will be a custom loop. They look cooler anyways lol.
    Thanks for both your inputs!

  5. #5
    Aside from the H100, most LCLC systems barely outperform high end air coolers, if at all. And when it comes to custom WCing loops, they aren't even in the same league.
    When it comes to the bling factor, they aren't even on the same planet

    That said, they are immensely easier to install and upkeep (essentially no upkeep), and considerably cheaper. I don't consider LCLC systems to be "water coolers" other then the fact that they are filled with some percentage of water. They just don't have the performance or flexibility of a custom water cooling loop. But I realize that for many they are a nice foray into the "exotic", and its nice to be able to tell people your computer is water cooled, even if that phrase looses most of its significance when it refers to LCLC systems.

  6. #6
    Wants Old Title Back
    Didn't Get It
    Conumdrum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Las Vegas
    Author Profile
    The 600t is a nice case, you should be able to fit a small custom loop in it. It should hold a H100 pretty well. but that's not custom.
    I want my old title back.
    Old beast is torn down.
    Will update later.

    900 watt (1500VA) UPS
    27" ASUS VG 3D/Nvidia V2 3D glasses and 24" Acer H243H

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts