OK, so about a week ago, I tried to stabilize my 4.5 GHz OC by turning on PLL Overvoltage and setting the PLL voltage to 1.820V. I also changed the Dynamic VCore to +0.095V. It worked. I ran Prime on blend for more than 24 hours with no BSOD. No problems with IBT either.
I don't why the hell I need suuuuuuch high voltages to hold the overclock. I am still unsure whether it's the CPU or the board...or both.
Regardless, I have been plagued with the boot loop issue upon cold boots. I wouldn't get past POST screen, and it would just loop for 4-6 times before getting a successful POST & into Windows. I've tried to change so many settings around, and on several occasions thought I fixed it, but the loop returns in a few days. I've searched around, and sooooooo many people are having the cold boot loop issue on the GA-Z68 boards. No one has any clear solution either. Apparently Gigabyte won't provide any solid fix, so I feel reeeally screwed.
Time for a new board maybe?