if you have a larger body of water, and you are not adding in any more heat, your max temp will be lower, how much i cant say, but you could add in say 2 gallons and let us know, also it would take longer to get up to temp, simply because there is more water to heat up, a metal ras will also allow a lower temp, because right now you are only cooling throuht the top, but a metal res will cool through 5 of the sides (dont know if it will cool down with carpet there, but it might.
also with a larg res like you have it is easy to add ICE to the setup to cool down the water temp rapildy, I know with my 2 liter setup if i put in about half the volume of water as ice cubes, i will drop mytemps for about an hour by 10c or more, just becarefull of how low you go with the water temp, because if you drop below the dew point, you can hurt stuff in your sytem, if it is not sealed up to protect against it.