MOR in the hizouse, as requested!!
Well, as far as I can see- this has nothing to do with your PSU, and everything to do with your motherboard. Some mobos have a lying Winbond monitoring chip, and some mobos have poorly regulated power circuits- although that is one hell of an error- 1.75 to 1.84? Geez! I would try to crank down the voltage if at all possible, and--
Wait a minute! Check the L1 +L2 bridges on the CPU, you can use those to choose voltage as well as unlock multipliers, you might have made an error with the pencil, some errant metal flakes, hand of God, etc.
And now that I've typed this I see youve already checked that...
Well maybe swab the top o the chip with alcohol and try it again just to be sure.
OK now all I can say is RMA that mobo for a new one. Preferably a different model, just to be safe. I have one other idea but it's a pain in the *** and it won't actually solve the problem- A CPU's heat output is directly propotional to the Vcore you give it; you could try ALL availible Vcore settings and see if the temps are a steady ramp or not. If not, you know the monitoring chip you have is flaky, if it is, you know that it isn't.
That's all I got. GL buddy!