Notices

Overclockers Forums > Hardware > Cooling > Water Cooling
Water Cooling Discussion devoted to blocks, pumps, radiators, reservoirs, tubing, and everything else to get you running smooth on a water loop
Forum Jump

The impact of tubing sizes

Post Reply New Thread Subscribe Search this Thread
 
 
Thread Tools
Old 06-12-07, 08:14 AM Thread Starter   #1
Cathar
Senior Member

 
Cathar's Avatar 

Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Melbourne, Australia

 
The impact of tubing sizes


I've been working on a wholistic guide to designing a water-cooling system of late. Using a mix of real-world test data, and calculating pressure drops, I've been able to put together an analysis of the impact of tubing sizes on CPU temperatures.

The radiator and waterblocks are:

Thermochill PA120.2 with 2 x Yate-Loon fans at 12v
Swiftech Apogee GTX
Conroe C2D CPU, overclocked and under load, emitting 100W of heat
2 meters of tubing length

Loop order is pump->radiator->waterblock->pump

Using 1/2" ID tubing and 1/2" OD barbs, I determined the pressure-drop curve for the system. Using Swiftech's published test data for the Apogee GTX, and a flow-performance curve for the PA120.2, we're able to determine the pumping hydraulic power required to push various flow-rates. Using established typical ratios of hydraulic power to actual power draw and heat dump of known real-world pumps, we're able to throw into the mix the amount of pump heat dump required to push any flow rate. We first establish this independently of an actual pump (i.e. determine the theoretical best pump), and then select an actual real-world pump that best suits the theoretical target, and then using the PQ curve of that pump, determine the final flow rate of the system, and hence the correspondent final CPU temperature.

Now in a wholistic model, we're modelling not just the impact of the water-flow rate on the CPU temperature, but the impact of the total heat dump of the cooling system (CPU, pump, radiator fans) has on the room environment, which in turn raises the temperature of the air in the room, and so in turn raises the water temperature because the air-in temperature into the radiator will have warmed up. The effect is very small, but I still model it.

Global temp = 22C
Room C/W = 0.005
Fan Heat Dump = 2.0W

The proposed tubing sizes and fittings we'll be investigating are:

6.35 (1/4") ID tubing with quick-fit fittings
8mm (5/16") ID tubing over 6mmID|8mmOD barbs
8mm (5/16") ID tubing with quick-fit fittings
9.6mm (3/8") ID tubing over 7.5mmID|3/8"OD barbs
9.6mm (3/8") ID tubing with quick-fit fittings
11.1mm (7/16") ID tubing stretched over 10.5mmID|1/2"OD barbs
12.7mm (1/2") ID tubing over 10.5mmID|1/2"OD barbs

Quick-fit fittings are those similar to those found on the Swiftech MCW50 (http://www.swiftech.com/products/mcw50.asp)

Running the above range of tubing/fitting sizes through the optimal pump power estimator software I wrote, it predicts that the best pump to use is one that's consuming around 10-13W, with optimal pumping efficiency in the ranges of 3-6LPM. I won't go into the intricacies of the pump power estimator. It's not an exact science, suffice to say that it looks at the wholistic scenario given a waterblock, heatload, room C/W, radiator, system restriction, and so on, and puts out a suggestion for where the optimal range of pumping power lies for that setup. This allows us to then pick a real pump that closely matches the suggested pumping characteristics.

Using the Laing data here: http://www.laing.de/file/66 we see that an unmodified DDC1+ (more commonly referred to in forums as the DDC2) is a very good pump fit for our scenario. Another excellent alternative would be the DDC1 with a modded top.

Okay, so our optimised system consists of:
Laing DDC1+ (unmodified)
Thermochill PA120.2 with 2 x Yate-Loon fans at 12v
Conroe C2D CPU, overclocked and under load, emitting 100W of heat
2 meters of tubing length

For the various tubing/fitting sizes, the PQ curves for a full system for each tubing type looks like this:



I overlaid the curves onto the PQ graph for the Laing DDC1+

The flow performance curves for the radiator and waterblock are illustrated on the following graphs:


...and...


The total CPU heat load is 100W. The total system heat load is 114W . We assume a fixed 14W heat dump from pump which was derived from other testing. This does in fact vary a little as we can see by the Laing graph. As flow rates decrease, so does power draw, and therefore the heat-dump as well. For simplicity we'll assume a fixed 14W heat dump for now.

The intersections all are:

6.35mm quick fit = 4.45LPM flow, 0.0795 block c/w, 0.0374 rad c/w
8mm barbed = 4.75LPM, 0.0783 block c/w, 0.0373 rad c/w
8mm quick fit = 5.6LPM, 0.0770 block c/w, 0.0369 rad c/w
9.6mm barbed = 5.7LPM, 0.0768 block c/w, 0.0369 rad c/w
9.6mm quick fit = 6.2LPM, 0.0762 block c/w, 0.0367 rad c/w
11.1mm barbed = 6.3LPM, 0.0761 block c/w, 0.0367 rad c/w
12.7mm barbed = 6.35LPM, 0.0760 block c/w, 0.0366 rad c/w

Final CPU temperature is ambient (22C) + system load (114W) * radiator C/W + CPU Load (100W) * block C/W

The final CPU temperatures work out to be:

6.35mm quick fit = 34.21C
8mm barbed = 34.08C
8mm quick fit = 33.91C
9.6mm barbed = 33.89C
9.6mm quick fit = 33.80C
11.1mm barbed = 33.79C
12.7mm barbed = 33.77C

So there we have it. The differences between varying tubing sizes.

Okay, the more astute of you will point out that the block C/W is really the case-to-block C/W, and that the actual CPU-die-to-block C/W is a lot higher. Even if we triple block the C/W (which would be an absolute upper limit based upon older research), we get:

6.35mm quick fit = 50.11C
8mm barbed = 49.74C
8mm quick fit = 49.31
9.6mm barbed = 49.25C
9.6mm quick fit = 49.04C
11.1mm barbed = 49.01C
12.7mm barbed = 49.00C

I'll leave it to everyone's own personal value based judgement to determine the relative importance of the differences seen....

It's certainly not the 5C figure that people bandy about. I never expected that it ever would be myself. In my own testing with arbitrarily choking the flow-rate in a test-system, I've always been amazed at the low flow resilience of many setups. Below 2LPM is where things start getting pear shaped quickly for most systems. My recommendation is that even if you're a low-flow fanatic, always ensure that your flow-rates are above 2LPM at the very least, and preferably above 3LPM if at all possible. Still, even when given 1/4" tubing installed with quick-fits and a decent pump like a DDC2, we can see that flow-rates in excess of 4LPM aren't a problem.

__________________
The Storm/G7 - making the Storm/G5 look like Duplo in comparison to the G7's Lego.
Cathar is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 08:25 AM   #2
WonderingSoul
Team 32 Folding Member



Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Crack the Skye

 
Great post Cathar!


I think this could be stickied.

__________________
Project Quick Bench
i7 920 - P6T Deluxe V2 - 6gb XMS3 1600 - 2x GTX 460 1GB in SLI - Corsair AX 850
HRT Music Streamer Pro > Rockhopper Beta 22 > HiFiMAN HE-500 / Sennheiser HD650
Heatware
WonderingSoul is offline Folding Profile Heatware Profile Rosetta Profile   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 12:14 PM   #3
tyshy
Member



Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Under your desk:)

 
I second the STICKY notion, definitely an interesting read, thanks for the info dude!

__________________
Don't Drown. It will ruin your day.

Heatware
tyshy is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 12:38 PM   #4
samuknow
Member

 
samuknow's Avatar 

Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Indianapolis, IN

10 Year Badge
 
That was great.

I feel like I just watched a better version of Mythbusters with actual scientific content.

__________________
Sam

"FEAR NOT" ISAIAH 41:10
HEAT
samuknow is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 05:28 PM   #5
jrafael
Registered

 
jrafael's Avatar 

Join Date: May 2007
Location: Tampa, FL

 
Glad to see there is almost no difference within 7/16 and 1/2

great job !

ps: as side note I think adding a few "non" standard waterpumps to the test like: Via Aqua 1300, Maxi-jet 1200, eheim 1048, Mag drive 2 or 3. and see if this less powefull pump will benefit from higher id tubing ?.

please excuse any typos or misspelling, my first lenguaje is spanish.
jrafael is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 06:35 PM   #6
samuknow
Member

 
samuknow's Avatar 

Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Indianapolis, IN

10 Year Badge
 
After really giving this a good look, I might go back to 3/8 tubing. I have a laing D4. Should be fine.

__________________
Sam

"FEAR NOT" ISAIAH 41:10
HEAT
samuknow is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 07:46 PM   #7
Mycobacteria
Member



Join Date: Dec 2006

 
So the bigger tubes win buy a little bit??
Mycobacteria is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 07:49 PM   #8
BLOOP!
Member

 
BLOOP!'s Avatar 

Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Los Angeles, CA

 
Mannn... I just bought 1/2" tygons and a custom top for my mcp350

__________________

SYSTEM:
ASRock P67 Extreme4 Gen3 - Intel i5 3570K @ 4.6GHz
Corsair Vengeance DDR3 2 x 4GB
MSI 7950 Twin Frozr 3GD5/OC 3GB - HP 2311xi 23" IPS
Intel 520 Series 180GB SSD
Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeMusic - Logitech Z-5500
Corsair HX620W
CASE & COOLING:
Swiftech Apogee - MCP350 + Swiftech MCR320-DRIVE REV3 Triple 120
NZXT Switch 810 Black
Mobile: Lumia 920 - Surface RT - Yoga 13
BLOOP! is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 07:50 PM   #9
aaronjb
Member



Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Lobsterland

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cathar
Now in a wholistic model, we're modelling not just the impact of the water-flow rate on the CPU temperature, but the impact of the total heat dump of the cooling system (CPU, pump, radiator fans) has on the room environment, which in turn raises the temperature of the air in the room, and so in turn raises the water temperature because the air-in temperature into the radiator will have warmed up. The effect is very small, but I still model it.
Awesome. Simply awesome. Thanks for the info, and thanks for doing this sort of testing and giving us the results. In a hobby filled with conjecture and blatant misinformation, it's nice to see that emperical results are still valued and published.

__________________
Not very active these days. PMs are the best way to reach me.

heatware

aaronjb is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 08:10 PM   #10
natewildes
Member

 
natewildes's Avatar 

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: USA

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BLOOP!
Mannn... I just bought 1/2" tygons and a custom top for my mcp350
Remember that Cathar tested flow rate on a system with only a given *length of tubing; if you position the setup horizontally (let's say on the floor), the flow rate will be much greater than if you put it vertically (like running tubing up a wall, rather than along the floor). The modified DDC top will not only give you greater flow rate, but you'll also see a pretty decent increase in head pressure, which is imperative for getting water to go against gravity. i.e.-unless your tubing is at a 0degree incline to gravity, you'll need head pressure to get it moving. The more pressure you have, the steeper (and longer) that incline can be.

__________________
Macbook Pro for life.
natewildes is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 08:43 PM   #11
EmAn
Member

 
EmAn's Avatar 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Ft. Hood Texas

 
very interesting and informative..

i vote sticky!

__________________
Cooler Master HAF 932 Asus P5Q-PRO E8400 4050mhz
Tuniq Tower 120 Crossfire Diamond HD4850's 512mb a piece
2x2 GB OCZ DDR2 1066 Platinum OCZ GameXStream 600W

SPC in the US ARMY working on AH-64D Appache Longbow Attack Helicopters
Yes I work on a $47,000,000 computer that has two jet engines attached to it A LOT of spinning parts and of course... Rockets, GUNS, and Missiles
EmAn is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 08:56 PM Thread Starter   #12
Cathar
Senior Member

 
Cathar's Avatar 

Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Melbourne, Australia

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by natewildes
Remember that Cathar tested flow rate on a system with only a given *length of tubing; if you position the setup horizontally (let's say on the floor), the flow rate will be much greater than if you put it vertically (like running tubing up a wall, rather than along the floor). The modified DDC top will not only give you greater flow rate, but you'll also see a pretty decent increase in head pressure, which is imperative for getting water to go against gravity. i.e.-unless your tubing is at a 0degree incline to gravity, you'll need head pressure to get it moving. The more pressure you have, the steeper (and longer) that incline can be.
In a closed loop system, gravity has no impact. Can lay it flat, or hang it high. The path "down" counterbalances the path "up" so the net gravitational influence is zero.

__________________
The Storm/G7 - making the Storm/G5 look like Duplo in comparison to the G7's Lego.
Cathar is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 09:26 PM   #13
Maviryk
Member

 
Maviryk's Avatar 

Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA

 
I think I just posted in something STICKY.

__________________
Toshiba Satellite E105
I'm packing Heat
Maviryk is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 09:35 PM   #14
nikhsub1
Unoriginal Macho Moderator

 
nikhsub1's Avatar 

Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Los Angeles

10 Year Badge
 
I will sticky this in time, if it is done now, IT WILL NEVER BE READ AGAIN ROFL. Seriously, stickys tend to get ignored. Bumping will do this good for a while,

__________________
Loading Signature ...
nikhsub1 is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 09:38 PM   #15
EmAn
Member

 
EmAn's Avatar 

Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Ft. Hood Texas

 
i dont ignore the stickies

and at least we know that it will be stickied!

__________________
Cooler Master HAF 932 Asus P5Q-PRO E8400 4050mhz
Tuniq Tower 120 Crossfire Diamond HD4850's 512mb a piece
2x2 GB OCZ DDR2 1066 Platinum OCZ GameXStream 600W

SPC in the US ARMY working on AH-64D Appache Longbow Attack Helicopters
Yes I work on a $47,000,000 computer that has two jet engines attached to it A LOT of spinning parts and of course... Rockets, GUNS, and Missiles
EmAn is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 09:39 PM   #16
natewildes
Member

 
natewildes's Avatar 

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: USA

 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cathar
In a closed loop system, gravity has no impact. Can lay it flat, or hang it high. The path "down" counterbalances the path "up" so the net gravitational influence is zero.
Damn you high school physics! haha, thanks for the clarification

__________________
Macbook Pro for life.
natewildes is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 11:06 PM   #17
Bageland2000
Member

 
Bageland2000's Avatar 

Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Chicago, IL

 
Completely worthless post, what a joke *drew hits flame gnome off his computer* sorry about that...STICKY MATERIAL. That helped a lot cathar thanks. I'm currently in the process of deciding what tubing to go with. I think I know now!

__________________
Main Rig............................................... .........HTPC
OS:Windows 7 x64......................................Windows 7 x64
Motherboard: ASRock z87 Extreme4............Gigabyte GA-G41M-ES2H
CPU: i5 4670K............................................. e6600
RAM: 2x4GB Crucial Ballistix TT 1866............2x2GB Patriot DDR2
GPU/VIDEO: Sapphire 6950 2GB..................Onboard, Hauppauge PVR-1800
HDD: Corsair Force GS 240GB SSD ..............Samsung 830 128GB SSD
Display: Hanns-G 28" 1080p.........................LG 42" LCD (42LD400)
Sound: Onboard........................................... Auzentech X-Mystique Gold, Logitech Z-5500

.:HEAT:.
Bageland2000 is online now Heatware Profile   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 11:20 PM   #18
Hazaro
Member

 
Hazaro's Avatar 

Join Date: Apr 2007

 
Hmm, I thought everyone already knew bigger is better

Very informative post.

__________________
2500K @4.2GHz, P8P67 PRO, 8GB G.Skill Sniper, RocketFish Case, 2x 6950, X750 PSU, TRUE120

Hazaro is offline   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-12-07, 11:41 PM   #19
muddocktor
Retired

 
muddocktor's Avatar 

Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: New Iberia, LA

10 Year Badge
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cathar
In a closed loop system, gravity has no impact. Can lay it flat, or hang it high. The path "down" counterbalances the path "up" so the net gravitational influence is zero.
Yep, basic U-tube principle. BTW, great post Cathar. I'm glad to see you put some concrete numbers down for everyone to read.
muddocktor is offline Author Profile Benching Profile Folding Profile SETI Profile Heatware Profile Rosetta Profile   QUOTE Thanks
Old 06-13-07, 12:23 AM   #20
Mycobacteria
Member



Join Date: Dec 2006

 
Does a system with large tubes hold more water compared to a system that used small tubes?

Would this difference in volume influence the temperature in any way?
Mycobacteria is offline   QUOTE Thanks

Post Reply New Thread Subscribe


Overclockers Forums > Hardware > Cooling > Water Cooling
Water Cooling Discussion devoted to blocks, pumps, radiators, reservoirs, tubing, and everything else to get you running smooth on a water loop
Forum Jump

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Mobile Skin
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:40 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
You can add these icons by updating your profile information to include your Heatware ID, Benching Profile ID or your Folding/SETI profile ID. Edit your profile!
X

Welcome to Overclockers.com

Create your username to jump into the discussion!

New members like you have made this the best community on the Internet since 1998!


(4 digit year)

Why Join Us?

  • Share experience
  • Max out your hardware
  • Best forum members anywhere
  • Customized forum experience

Already a member?