HTIB vs. Receiver + Bookshelf

[jman999]

The RCA RT2600 can be bought on ebay for $125 shipped or less. I am considering this or a receiver and a pair of HKB 6's.

Now I know that the sound quality of the HKB 6 will beat that of cheap HTS speakers, but I kind of want Surround sound for movies. I listen to some music, but the primary purpose of this system is movies.

Is surround sound worth the decrease in sound quality?

I know it's opinion based, but I'm having trouble deciding,

Thanks, Jonathan.

 

[corebreach]

Go for the high quality HKB 6 route. Surround sound is a nice effect, but I wouldn't say it improves the moviewatching experience. Things that happen on screen are audio spatialized in front of you, and the rest is just ambience.

 

[seamadan000]

if you watch action movies the surround sound is IMHO more important than the quality increase you would get with the bookshelves. Also, the HTIB would have a sub, and that will be a big bonus for watching movies.

 

[stratcatprowlin]

I think you should go for the quality speakers and reciever.You can always add more speakers later when you have more money.Even in stereo your movies will sound better than 5 cheap speakers and a crappy sub.

At least the system is upgradable this way.Start with a good foundation and you will never be sorry later.

 

[jman999]

Well I can always add a sub later to my Speaker system.

It's just so hard trying to get quality components on my budget (<$150). But eventually I'll win one of the bidding wars on the receivers.

Thanks, for your 2 cents, Jonathan.

 

[corebreach]

Well I can always add a sub later to my Speaker system.

It's just so hard trying to get quality components on my budget (<$150). But eventually I'll win one of the bidding wars on the receivers.

Thanks, for your 2 cents, Jonathan.

If you know any really kind people with old receivers, hit them up for one. I just got a really nice Pioneer SX-1250 (160W/channel!) for $30.

 

[Azzkiller]

I personally would get an inexpensive surround receiver and the HK's. For now, you could get even a cheap pair of speakers for 10-30 dollars if you really need surround, and then upgrade later.

 

[jman999]

I went and did something stupid. I bought a JBL Cinema Propack 600 for $260 shipped. It's way over my budget and I'm trying to get out of it. I'll probably end up having to pay for it though.

-Jonathan.

EDIT: He's relisting. What a relief.

 

[stratcatprowlin]

Every dollar I spend is over my budjet so dont feel bad.