OK I get it now. Well I agree that returning a mobo because you couldn't get it to oc as much as you'd hoped is wrong. I agree that there is a real problem, however big or small, of some oc'ers acting in an underhanded way.
I'm not sure what else to do about it other than acknowledge the situation. I already operate with ethical standards, I'm a professional, and I like to look myself in the mirror, sleep at night. But I haven't fooled myself into thinking I have any measure of control over how some of the more unthinking members may behave. True, we may raise awareness and get a few folks to think of some things they haven't thought of before, but beyond that there's certainly no hope of enforcing any code. I wonder what sort of content might fill this proposed website, and how much traffic it might sustain after the first big bang.
Well I'm all for it, and I sure wouldn'tr dream of standing in the way, but when you look at the cost-reward ratio i think we may get the best return just by cultivating awareness on the board, and perhaps levy access penalties for transgressions. If someone comes swaggering in bragging about how they justsent bacfk a stick of ram because they didn't get 40% more speed than the thing is rated, well then they get a tongue lashing and sent to bed without dinner.
But a website? What would go there other than a mission statement and ethical code? We could do that here in the FAQ.