• Welcome to Overclockers Forums! Join us to reply in threads, receive reduced ads, and to customize your site experience!

Thermaltake Pacific RL240 vs XSPC Raystorm DDC Photon RX240 V3 vs EK-X240

Overclockers is supported by our readers. When you click a link to make a purchase, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

pompeytom247

New Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
XSPC Raystorm DDC Photon RX240 Comparison Test.
Following my review of the Thermaltake Pacific RL240 water cooling kit, I thought it about time that Thermaltake Pacific RL240 was tested against the competitors in market place.
First I’m going to look at the XSPC Raystorm DDC Photon RX240 V3. The XSPX Raystorm kit again includes everything ¬¬¬¬that you will require to complete your water cooling loop. However one thing that was apparent straight away was that there was no premixed coolant supplied & for the price of this kit coming in at around £244.80 it’s a shame that £10 worth of premixed coolant has not been included.
The XSPC kit once taken out of the plain brown box is of high quality, a long way from the early XSPC water cooling components.
The kit includes,
Raystorm CPU cooler - Acetal
Photon reservoir 170 incl. Pump
RX240 V3 Dual radiator (240 mm)
6x fittings G1 / 4 inch to 1/2 inch - Black Chrome
2x 120 mm fan (1,650 U / min)
2x fan grill - black
Installation material for Intel and AMD
2x 3-mm blue LED (4-pin Molex connector)
1x blue 5mm LED (4-pin Molex connector)
2 m of transparent tube (inner diameter: 11 mm)
24-pin ATX Power Jumper
K2 Thermal Compound
compatibility:
Intel LGA 775, 1150, 1155, 1156, 1366, 2011 2011 V3
AMD Socket AM2, AM2 +, AM3, AM3 +, FM1, FM2, FM2 +
1_zpsxx6xedv1.jpg

2_zpsf8hjrbwd.jpg

3_zpssfjp9lta.jpg

I’m taking a brief look at each of the XSPC Water cooling kit components, before assembly into the chassis.
CPU Water block – The Raystorm is well constructed using a copper base & well CNC’d fin arrangement, the Acetal top is nicely finished & the block comes with all the necessary fitting brackets to cover all known sockets.
4_zpsaqlsosaf.jpg

5_zps3fdxwnwd.jpg

7_zpspn1sxpfi.jpg

8_zpsyot3blxq.jpg


- - - Updated - - -

Pump reservoir combo – is again well constructed & the pump is Laing D5 just like the Thermaltake unit. Again the speed is set to No:- 2 of the Laing D5 Vario pump which insures that the pump operation is very quiet.
16_zpsyvfhxfva.jpg

17_zpsc1ndqosd.jpg

Radiator – The RX240 V3 Dual radiator (240 mm). I’ve used many of these in the past in water cooling systems, from the old RS radiators right up to the new RX range with no problems whatsoever. The RX240radiator uses a copper & brass core & is more than efficient in the modern water cooling world.
18_zpscdu6tnjx.jpg

Fittings & Hose – The fittings have come a long way since the early years of XSPC compression fitting. The Black Chrome 3/8” fittings supplied have a good finish with no blemishes during the chroming process & have a well manufactured thread making these easy to tighten. The hose supplied is 3/8”
I.D & 5/8” O.D. It not Tygon by any means but is supple enough to obtain a good radius bend.

9_zpsi0yxhgyr.jpg

10_zpsu7stu7rc.jpg

Cooling Fans – The fans are of reasonable quality running at a full speed of 1650 R.P.M & XSPC offer 2x fan guards which is a good idea if you don’t want your fingers hit by the fans, but also add a slight restriction to the air flow.

11_zpsn4nhjysw.jpg

19_zpsx9n9cmfc.jpg

Using the same test rig / chassis as used for the Thermaltake Pacific RL240 test, only 4x 4.5mm holes were required to be drilled into the Thermaltake F51 chassis to mount the XSPC Pump / reservoir combo.
13_zpsjrso6rsy.jpg

Once the pump reservoir combo is fitted in position in the Thermaltake chassis, I’ve opted to fit the radiator again in the same layout as the Thermaltake kit. This is so I can make a comparative test for each kit or at least as close as possible.
12_zpsqhopb3ka.jpg

The Raystorm water block fitted very well onto the test motherboard & with the LED lighting supplied it does look pretty trick, if you like that sort of thing.
After purchasing some cooling fluid that was not supplied in the kit, I’ve used XSPC’s own EC6 Non Conductive Coolant - UV Blue. The system was filled & soon bled without issue after a few times of turning the pump on & off.

15_zpstnjuvrzv.jpg


- - - Updated - - -

Testing the thermal properties - The important part of the review!

Using exactly the same hardware as per the Thermaltake Pacific RL240 test previously carried out & the ambient temperature at almost the same, I set prime95 running & periodically took screen shots of the test rig temperatures below,

21_zpswtqhxegm.jpg


23_zps4o6lunv3.jpg


22_zps7ls1j9ix.jpg


The XSPC Raystorm DDC Photon RX240 V3 does not perform as well against the Thermaltake Pacific RL240 water cooling kit, although nothing to really split hairs over to be honest.
The ambient temperature was slightly lower 1-2c than when the Thermaltake kit was tested.

Next I am going to be testing an EK KIT-X240 & I think that there is not going to be much difference in performance between all three 240mm kits I’m testing, it is going to come down to cost, looks & manufacturer.

Once the last report is finished, I shall make a brief conclusion to all three kits tested, performance, looks, ease of fitment & value for money.
 

Conumdrum

Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2007
Location
Small town Emlenton, PA
Nice. Correcting your final result values with ambient temps should show they are pretty close. And the 1-3C difference in block mounting. If you mount each CPU block 3 times and do the full tests and take an average, that would help to see if there is a real diff in the units.