From what I read, it seems that an uneven IHS and coldplate/heatsink plate are not even uncommon. Is this one very far from flat ( I'll admit I kind of glossed over the part where he said exactly how it stood up to the paper test) ? From looking at the pics of the tim, it doesn't look outright terrible - maybe like it just needs to be brought back into "true" (flat)? I've never actually done such a thing before though so haven't got much idea how much work goes into it. And are we sure there isn't just a generic Tim in use here? Is it possible he's just maxed out the thermal conductivity of a poor tim?
(BTW I'm kinda just asking for my own benefit, if these answers are obvious... Well I missed it in the reading or they're not obvious at my knowledge level
)