SUMMARY: Probably the first of many 80 mm “fandapter” heatsinks. The stock fan does not cut it for Socket A, but a Panaflo gets it into acceptable territory.
Well what have we here? A 60mm on steroids? No – it’s an 80mm fan on what looks like a 60mm heatsink (at least compared to some other 80mm socket heatsinks). This is from Winink Corp, another newcomer to the heatsink scene.
The Tornado features a Socket A/370 heatsink footprint at the base and uses the kind of clip we all love – engages one lug of the socket and requires a screwdriver to place on/off. At the top is the “fandapter” for the 80mm fan.
Note that this does not have a taper – it has no real depth and is literally just an adapter. The fan is held in place by the two plastic uprights – the fan snaps into place. You may have to wiggle it a bit to do this, as the fit is snug.
The base is gold plated copper – very pretty but really unnecessary. The base is very smooth – no machining marks of any kind. Hopefully consumers who purchase this unit will see the same base.
As you look down into it, you can see lots of fins – good airflow through the heatsink. The fan snaps into the plastic top – no screws; this makes changing the fan a snap.
There is one problem, however:
It is impossible to mount this heatsink with the fan in place.
The clip requires a screwdriver to engage the socket’s lugs; given the angle of the clip and the overhang of the plastic top, there’s no way you can get a screwdriver into the clip to rotate it onto the socket’s lugs.
So, what you have to do is remove the fan, mount the heatsink on the socket, and then snap the fan into place. Easy enough to do, except that it makes me wonder if all this snapping and wiggling into place can potentially damage the CPU’s core. I did it at least a dozen times without a problem, but be warned what’s required.
I prepared the Tornado by boring a hole completely through the base so I could epoxy a thermocouple above the CPU. The thermocouple is attached to an Omega HH23 Digital Thermometer. Ambient temps were measured with a thermocouple placed about 1 inch from the fan’s intake. I used Prime 95 to stress the CPU on an Iwill KK266, BD133 (MBM temps are on-die) and Abit KT7. Arctic Silver grease was used in all tests. CPU Case Temp is the temp at that point where the CPU contacts the heatsink, CPU Back Temps are measured by a thermocouple on the center back of the CPU.
The stock fan (ARX) was pretty wimpy – very quiet (55 dBA, 2900 rpm) but its performance was barely acceptable for aggressive Socket A cooling. I tried a few different 80mms and found the Panaflo FBA08A12H (61 dBA, 3000 rpm) a much better performer at noise about at the YS Tech level. The best performer was the Sanyo Denki 109P0812A201 (4600 rpm, 66 dBA) at the expense of higher noise and for a minimal gain (about 1C – remember diminishing returns?), so I elected used the Panaflo in all tests.
Substituting an 80mm fan for a 60mm is not as simple as looking at equal cfms. For a rough approximation to determine equivalency between a 60mm and 80mm fan, use the following formula can:
Fan Tip Speed in feet/min = ((pi * fan diameter inches * fan rpm)/12)/60
A 3000 rpm 80mm fan is about the same as a 4000 rpm 60mm fan, and a 4600 rpm 80mm is about the same as a 6100 rpm 60 mm. It would take an 80mm fan spinning about 5250 rpm to equal a Delta 38 at 7000 rpm. This does not take into account pressure, which will have a marked influence on any comparison. Also note that sound levels will be about the same for equivalent fans.
The Tornado shipped with the fan blowing into the heatsink – it was 1-2 dBA quieter and performed slightly worse than with the fan blowing out, so I elected to test with the fans blowing out. Depending on each user’s system, results may vary.
CPU Case Temp
CPU Back Temp
|T-Bird @ 1397/Iwill KK266 ARX fan (99 watts)|
|T-Bird @ 1397/Iwill KK266 Sanyo fan (99 watts)|
|T-Bird @ 1397/Iwill KK266 Panaflo fan (99 watts)|
|Duron @ 1000/ABIT KT7 Panaflo fan (64 watts)|
|PIII @ 933/Iwill BD133 Panaflo fan (26 watts)|
C/W = Delta / CPU Watts
Interpreting C/W: For every watt the CPU radiates, the heatsink will cool the core by the (C/W x watts) plus ambient temp. For example, at an ambient temp of 25 C, a C/W of 0.25 with a CPU radiating 50 watts means that the CPU temp will be 50 x 0.25 = 12.5 C over ambient temp, or 37.5 C. The lower the C/W, the better.
The increased performance with the Panaflo amounts to a 5C difference for a 100 watt CPU – a nice gain. However, there are limits – the Sanyo is a more powerful but yields very little gain for the extra noise. Also note that with all this horsepower, the Tornado comes in at about 0.25 C/W – more aggressive 80mms do not propel it into the top ranks.
The Tornado is a good example of the benefits of integrating an 80mm fan for Socket A/370 cooling: Acceptable performance at relatively modest noise levels. However, simply slapping an 80mm fan and a fandapter on a 60mm heatsink IS NOT going to give you Delta 38 performance at YS Tech noise levels.
A fan’s cfm rating is only part of the story – the fan’s performance curve must be matched to the heatsink’s system resistance for optimal performance. You may go through a few fans before finding the best one; if you don’t have some lying around, it could be an expensive experiment.
Optimizing performance is a complex balance of each fan’s operating parameters and heatsink characteristics. We will do some more on this topic in future articles.
I you are interested in carrying the Tornado, Contact Winink Here.