X58 Motherboard Safari, which one is right for you?

We have all now seen the latest offerings for P55 chipset motherboards. For many it was the best board for their needs and they upgraded. I found that there are still many undecided folks still delaying the decision to upgrade their computers. They are generally happy with the current performance of their rig but the remaining life span of their system is still in the back of their minds. I am going to stick my neck out and say that maybe another look at the x58 chipset motherboards just might help them find their way to that upgrade. Most people say to themselves, “If I’m going to invest a fair amount of my hard earned dollars, I want the best board that fits my needs.” So let’s venture out on a high-tech safari and travel to that X58 jungle in Silicon Valley and see what hardware we can prey on.

There are many choices amongst X58 boards nowadays but which is the best for you? Well, to help determine what the best motherboard is we need to determine the recipe that makes for the best board. The best board to someone who is on a budget is different than one for, let’s say, a person that has Bill Gates’ budget. The best board for a gamer may not suit someone that is an extreme overclocker. So we have a lot to consider when we want the best board.

One of the best places to see what’s offered on the market is Newegg.com, which has 38 different motherboards by 11 different manufacturers. Of the companies, Asus has the most models with 11 , followed by EVGA with six, MSI five, Asrock four, Foxconn and Gigabyte with three  each, ECS with two, followed by Biostar, Jetway, and SuperMicro tied with just one board. Price-wise, the highest cost board is the EVGA 762 Classified at $499.99 with the Foxconn Flaming Blade priced the lowest at $154.99. This is a rather large range of boards to deal with, so we are going to break it up. We’ll divide and conquer to find the best board for each market segment. The segments we are going to look at are:

  • Entry level –  A budget type board with some overclocking capability
  • Enthusiast/gamer – Mid-range cost and features board that can do some heavy overclocking on premium air or water.
  • Finally, a full feature board that can be used by extreme benchers / overclockers and generally has the most flexibility in its bios settings.


In the entry level segment ($210 or less) we picked three from a field of nine boards. These boards have all the necessities to get the job done. They are the best boards for someone who has a limited budget and is looking for the “best bang for the buck” or maybe someone who is just darn thrifty with their money. We can also include the media PC guys that are looking for a small form factor. They fit right into this segment as the smaller the board, the less it generally costs to make it. Also note that manufacturers tend to remove components to make it smaller. The biggest target for component chopping are PCI slots.

Foxconn Flaming Blade GTI


For the Enthusiast/Gamer segment it is a bit more difficult to find the best because there are more ingredients in the recipe. Here we are less concerned about price and size but looking for features, durability, name brand, board layout and pcix16 slots. The Enthusiast is looking with a more critical eye at the looks and functionality of the board.


The last segment is the extremist who goes all out with no regard for price and is just looking for raw potential to get a new world record. These guys dive off cliffs, jump out of airplanes and get lots of speeding tickets. These guys will fry a CPU, burn the sockets and crack the boards trying to top their top bench records. Only the most high-end boards fall in this category.

The X58 line is full and it has something for everybody. Combined with a Bloomfield processor, you will have a real number cruncher that’s fast…very fast. So to those that are undecided, it is time to upgrade. The X58 based motherboards are the best on the market. Go straight to your favorite technology store and buy one or two.


Loading new replies...

Avatar of I.M.O.G.

Glorious Leader

25,037 messages 3 likes

Really good read alien, your breakdown is definitely going to be helpful for people in the market to get a new board!

Reply Like

Avatar of fire2havoc


190 messages 0 likes

Good breakdown. I would add the ASUS P6T/P6T SE to the entry-level. I would also add the Gigabyte EX58-UD4P to the mid-range. And I would add the ASUS P6X58D and Gigabyte X58A-UD7 to the upper tier.

Reply Like

Avatar of Gabkicks


1,571 messages 0 likes

very nice :) I got to skim the article and I'll try to read it thuroughly in the morning, but i was wondering why my mobo was left out? was it because they didnt send one for you to test? i got it for around $170 shipped.

Reply Like

Avatar of Alien432

Tech Savvy Member

558 messages 0 likes

Yep, quick read with lots of information. A few new boards have entered the market after article was written so look for follow-up article.

Reply Like