I got G Skill 1600 7-8-7-24 1.35V Eco ram and it is doing well for me. (
Linky ) Got them for $105. There was other sets but I went with the cheaper option.
For inital testing it went up to 1800 with some more voltage, like 1.45V if I remember, maybe a bit more. That's with keeping the 7-8-7-24 1T timings.
MB is P7P55D-E, and I5 760. Booted into windows at 4.3 and Prime'd a bit but just working on a 4.1GHz 24/7 clock just to keep the temps down (I am just gaming, not benching).
Anyways, when I was looking, I read a lot of good things about G Skill in general right now, including the 2 mentioned above.
Side note, during my MMORPG days I never hit more then 3.4GB of total ram usage, so I just went with 4GB this tiem around.
And yes, e-tailers will be much cheaper then Best Buy!!