Best cooling for ASUS P5B-D...Thermalright Ultra-120 or Scythe Infinity?

[kfc]

..

..

 

[nd4spdbh2]

Ultra 120 FTW.... the ultra 120 is ever so slighly better than the ninja.... and the ninja is better than the infinity.... so Ultra 120> ninja > infinity..... so ULTRA 120 is the winner!... i have one on my P5W dh (pretty much the same board) on top of my E6600 and it keeps it COOOL!

 

[greenmaji]

Were is the testing that showed that the Ninja is better then the Infinity?

 

[enz660]

Ultra 120 FTW.... the ultra 120 is ever so slighly better than the ninja.... and the ninja is better than the infinity.... so Ultra 120> ninja > infinity..... so ULTRA 120 is the winner!... i have one on my P5W dh (pretty much the same board) on top of my E6600 and it keeps it COOOL!

just wondering? what kinda ambient temps you have and what temps you are getting with that heatsink + what cfm fan you have on it..

 

[shole01]

There's a recent review on teh Thermalright Ultra-120 at Madshrimps

results:
http://www.madshrimps.be/?action=getarticle&number=4&artpage=2077&articID=496

Seems good with low voltage but seems to struggle when increasing vcore

 

[nvidiaOCmaster]

you need a big, heavy heatsink with alot of heatpipes for increased voltages.

 

[Immortal_Hero]

you need a big, heavy heatsink with alot of heatpipes for increased voltages.

Actually you just need a well designed HSF big/heavy doesn't = good...

 

[nd4spdbh2]

Were is the testing that showed that the Ninja is better then the Infinity?

silentpcreview the ninja slightly beat out the infinity.... the ninja has more heat pipes.