• Welcome to Overclockers Forums! Join us to reply in threads, receive reduced ads, and to customize your site experience!

SLI Power Consumption Results - JonnyGuru

Overclockers is supported by our readers. When you click a link to make a purchase, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

Spawne32

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Location
NJ
Sorry if this has been previously posted, just thought id bring it to everyones attention about PSU recommendations.


http://www.jonnyguru.net/forums/showthread.php?t=3137

Ran a few tests. Thought I'd share. Not going into much detail because I don't want to get into an Anandtechesque ****ing contest.

The following numbers are all DC, not AC, so there is no need to factor in PSU efficiency.

The numbers may be high because these are accumulative results. Current was measured at multiple points in the system and were then added together to provide the numbers below.

On the other hand, the response time of the test equipment is > 40mS, so transient loads that may hit the PSU faster than 40mS would not be picked up by the equipment.

Tests were actually performed with an 800W (unless stated otherwise) with a single +12V rail, but I've broken the load down into two rails to help illustrate the power distribution. The "CPU rail" is labeled +12V2 in my tests.

Build one:

680i board w/ QX6800, 2x1GB PC2 8500, two Seagate SATA drives in RAID0, one optical, one floppy, three fans run at full RPM, no PCI-e cards, on board sound, NIC, etc. USB KBD and mouse. Room temperature is just around 23.5C.

Build two:

Same parts with dual FX72's on a 680a based LIN64-SLI board. RAM upgraded to four 1GB PC2 8500 due to the nature of the platform.

Let the fun begin....

6800 GT 256MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 1
Total: 410W DC.
Total +12V2: 6.77A
Total +12V1: 21.7A

Comments:

Clearly this doesn't need much power, and will presumably work fine even if dual +12V rails (at no less than 18A each) are implemented. Since a 400W to 450W PSU does not typically have 18A and higher +12V rails, it is suggested a single +12V rail unit is used (i.e. Corsair VX450W.)

6800 GT 256MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 2
Total: 556W DC.
Total +12V2: 13A
Total +12V1: 25.7A

Comments:

Certainly we have a GPU bottle neck here. The +12V2 consumption goes up because of two CPU's, but also the +12V1 and total power consumption goes up because of the dual Northbridge design (a 680a is essentially two 590 chips.) I would say you can certainly "get by" with a 550W or 600W with dual +12V rails (20A each, I would hope) but would rather recommend a 600W with either a single +12V rail or four +12V rails or greater (like a SilverStone Strider ST60F or Corsair HX620W.)

7950 GT 256MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 1
Total: 444W DC.
Total +12V2: 8.2A
Total +12V1: 21.6A

Comments:

Power consumption here is very similar to the 6800 cards. Apparently some CPU bottlenecking is freed up, but power consumption isn't great enough for me to recommend anything different.

7950 GT 256MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 2
Total: 602W DC.
Total +12V2: 13A
Total +12V1: 29.4A

Comments:

Power consumption here is very similar to that of the 6800 cards. Again, it seems as if some CPU bottlenecking is freed up. I'm definitely suggesting that single +12V rail 600W and up here. If a single +12V rail solution isn't availble, feel free to use a 700W and up with four +12V rails (like the Etasis 750W/SilverStone Zeus ST75ZF.)

8800 GTS 640MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 1
Total: 484W DC.
Total +12V2: 8A
Total +12V1: 24.6A

Comments:

Not much different going on here still. The current going through the 8-pin (which may be supplying current to the CPU, but also to other parts of the board) went down a little, but the rest of the +12V consumption went up a little. A single +12V rail 500W and up (like the Corsair HX520W or Ultra X-Pro/X3 600W) or 600W and up with four +12V rails or more (like the SilverStone Strider ST60F) would be a good candidate here.

8800 GTS 640MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 2
Total: 656W DC.
Total +12V2: 13.7A
Total +12V1: 33.4A

Comments:

Power consumption here has gone up across the board. I'm going to recommend a minimum 700W here (like the Seasonic M12 700W, PC Power & Cooling 750W or the Etasis 750W/SilverStone Zeus ST75ZF.)

8800 GTX 768MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 1
Total: 527W DC.
Total +12V2: 7.2A
Total +12V1: 30.2A

Comments:

It's interesting to see the power consumption via the 8-pin EPS12V connector gradually go down with each set of cards. Going from the 6800 to 7950, we apparently unleashed a GPU bottleneck. But now it seems as if we're seeing a CPU bottleneck. Once again, a decent 600W, as long as it doesn't have two +12V rails, is going to be adequate.

8800 GTX 768MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 2
Total: 715W DC.
Total +12V2: 14.3A
Total +12V1: 41.1A

Comments:

Although I'm using an 800W PSU right now, I will say that I've tried to power this exact config with less than a 700W and it failed to even boot into the OS (using Corsair HX620W, Ultra X-Pro 600W and Thermaltake Toughpower 600W.) A minimum 700W is suggested, and a single +12V rail at the (Seasonic M12 700W or PC Power & Cooling Silencer 750W.) If only PSU's with split +12V rails are available, I suggest an 800W or up (like the Etasis 850W/SilverStone Zeus ST85ZF.)

8800 Ultra 768MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 1
Total: 636W DC.
Total +12V2: 10.3A
Total +12V1: 33A

Comments: We finally out grow the 600W suggestion and now move into the realm of 700W and up. 750W and up for PSU's with split +12V rails. The +12V2 consumption jumps way up. Obviously more juice is being drawn through this connector than the CPU can actually use, so I imagine that the resistance from the +12V lead on the main 24-pin connector is causing the board to pull power from wherever possible.

8800 Ultra 768MB x 2 SLI bridge on build 2
Total: 859W DC.
Total +12V2: 17.8A
Total +12V1: 45.6A

Comments: Remember when I said that I was using an 800W unless stated otherwise? Well.. here is my otherwise. During testing, I'd see the AC meter hit 1000W AC and.... THUD! PC would shut off or lock up. Even when the 800W was swapped out with a 1000W with four +12V rails I would shut down when power consumption hit 800W DC. Got to make sure that if you're using a pair of Ultra's on a quad FX rig that your PSU is at least 1000W with a single +12V rail (Ultra X3 1000W, PC Power & Cooling Turbo Cool 1000W) or has five or six +12V rails if they do split them up (yes, this exists. Topower built 1000W and up units often have five or six +12V rails.) If you're going with a PSU with four +12V rails, do check the power distribution. Make sure the OCP is at least 20A per rail, NOT 18A, and that there are no more than two PCI-e connectors on each of their +12V rails. No sharing with the 24-pin or any peripheral connectors.
 
Wow,

The cost of gaming really grows, eh? $2500+ for Tower, Monitor, Speakers, Gadgets, and then who knows how much more for electricity use, the $50+/game, and then taking into account the medical bills for CVD and diabetes inherited by a gamers sedentary lifestyle!

I can't wait till Fallout 3 comes out. :)

bryan d
 
And how many people actually have 2 SLI 8800 Ultras LOL? One 8800 Ultra is worth more than my entire rig put together haha.

But yes great list...It does show the power consumption that some of these graphics card's uses.
 
It also shows that a killAWatt is not always accurate. It does not account for harmonic distortion and phase mismatch between V and I.
 
Interesting read :)

...although I cant help but feel I read that before.

C_A,

Yes, I posted that link in one of the other power supply threads a week or so ago as part of the discussion. It probably was a good idea to post it as a standalone thread like this one.
 
That is basically reactive power that you are talking about, correct?

In part, when there is a phase mismatch, yes. But harmonic distortion is not accounted for.

PS# Sorry man. I hit edit post button instead of quote. That is why your post says last edited by S-N.
 
And how many people actually have 2 SLI 8800 Ultras LOL? One 8800 Ultra is worth more than my entire rig put together haha.

But yes great list...It does show the power consumption that some of these graphics card's uses.

Me too, but then again our systems are pretty much the same.

I'm not a big fan of SLI/Crossfire in general as I don't feel like the performance advantages outweigh the actual price, but to each his own.

Wow,

The cost of gaming really grows, eh? $2500+ for Tower, Monitor, Speakers, Gadgets, and then who knows how much more for electricity use, the $50+/game, and then taking into account the medical bills for CVD and diabetes inherited by a gamers sedentary lifestyle!

I can't wait till Fallout 3 comes out.

bryan d

PC gaming is expensive, but its only as expensive as you want it to be. For less than $1,200 you could build a gaming machine that would play pretty much any game at 1680x1050 with high detail (maybe not with AA) that would look as good or better than it does on any of the consoles, and thats including a 20" LCD monitor and decent KB/mouse and headset. Such a PC would also consume like 150W at idle, 200-250W while folding, and like 350W at full load.
 
Me too, but then again our systems are pretty much the same.

I'm not a big fan of SLI/Crossfire in general as I don't feel like the performance advantages outweigh the actual price, but to each his own.



PC gaming is expensive, but its only as expensive as you want it to be. For less than $1,200 you could build a gaming machine that would play pretty much any game at 1680x1050 with high detail (maybe not with AA) that would look as good or better than it does on any of the consoles, and thats including a 20" LCD monitor and decent KB/mouse and headset. Such a PC would also consume like 150W at idle, 200-250W while folding, and like 350W at full load.
yup very true. That system you could even throw in a Quad Core now. I for one will never do SLI or a CF setup. Its just a waste on money. Rather have 1 single high performance card. Corsair was smart bringing out high efficient, solid voltage regulation PSU's for cheap. There 450VX is a fantastic deal. With PSU's watts do not always matter.
 
And how many people actually have 2 SLI 8800 Ultras LOL? One 8800 Ultra is worth more than my entire rig put together haha.

But yes great list...It does show the power consumption that some of these graphics card's uses.

PC.JPG


One of my builds... Q6600, 2 Geforce 8800ultra's in SLI, 4gb DDR2 667 Ballistix, SATA DL DVD Burner, sata2 500gb maxtor, 150gb raptor put in after photo was taken, xfx 680i A+ edition mobo, Rosewell 850watt PSU, Centurion 534 case.

Great info Spawne32.
 
Back