• Welcome to Overclockers Forums! Join us to reply in threads, receive reduced ads, and to customize your site experience!

AMD or Intel for laptop?

Overclockers is supported by our readers. When you click a link to make a purchase, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

dlk289

Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
The title pretty much says it all. I would like to know what is the best to purchase?
The pro/cons?
I plan to buy my laptop august 1st if that changes anything...
Thanks for the response.
 
Last edited:
well intel is going to have socket P out by then with the faster C2D's in lappies. pretty much C2D is the way to go from intel. the only con i can think of is that it will cost slightly more then the amd counter parts.
 
Evilsizer said:
well intel is going to have socket P out by then with the faster C2D's in lappies. pretty much C2D is the way to go from intel. the only con i can think of is that it will cost slightly more then the amd counter parts.

It will... but currently it doesn't. Really... in terms of longevity and what's currently available... Intel and the C2D is the only game in town. Don't just look at the "megahertz"... look at the L2 Cache... and definately look at the video card. AMD laptops hae a slight advantage in the graphics department... but you can pretty much get the same cards in C2D... they just aren't as common.

It's sort of odd that ATI is in a situation where they have to sell graphics chips on Intel laptops to remain competitive in the market even thought they're currently owned by AMD... but hey!

With current Intel laptops (on the 479 architecture) you can upgrade your processor and everything except for the video card. So I'd say get the best built-in graphics available.
 
rainless said:
With current Intel laptops (on the 479 architecture) you can upgrade your processor........
this is only true if the laptop has a yohan based cpu and he upgrades to the meron.
the new socket P cpu's are not the same to 479, as i recall they are going to be pinless like lga but not the same layout.


http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=3180
http://news.softpedia.com/news/Deta...pcoming-Socket-P-Mobile-Processor-29166.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socket_P

as you can see here the socket P cpus are listed on intel's site.
http://processorfinder.intel.com/List.aspx?ProcFam=2643&sSpec=&OrdCode=
now we just wait for them to show up in lappies.

*edit*
ok so they still are using pins... maybe its the next gen then...
 
Last edited:
essientally the C2D lappies KILL anything amd has to offer... i mean their highest mobile chip is i think 2.33ghz? and only consumes 35w fully loaded... if im not mistaken amd has nothing to compare... and thoes mobile C2D's are DISGUSTINGLY fast its redicolus... we got all new iMac 17inchers with "only" 2.0ghz mobile c2d chips (apple uses all mobile stuff in their imacs) for our mac lab at my high school.. and i ran super pi in parallels with windows xp. (essientally it runs windows xp as a virtual machine on top of OSX) and it ran a 26sec super pi 1m i was amazed... my E6600 @ stock 2.4ghz desktop chip with 1066fsb (not the 667fsb of mobile chips) and with ddr2 800 does 21secs super pi 1m... although at 3ghz it does 17 secs... and 4ghz it does 12.609 :beer:


go with a intel c2d lappy
 
nd4spdbh2 said:
essientally the C2D lappies KILL anything amd has to offer... i mean their highest mobile chip is i think 2.33ghz? and only consumes 35w fully loaded... if im not mistaken amd has nothing to compare... and thoes mobile C2D's are DISGUSTINGLY fast its redicolus... we got all new iMac 17inchers with "only" 2.0ghz mobile c2d chips (apple uses all mobile stuff in their imacs) for our mac lab at my high school.. and i ran super pi in parallels with windows xp. (essientally it runs windows xp as a virtual machine on top of OSX) and it ran a 26sec super pi 1m i was amazed... my E6600 @ stock 2.4ghz desktop chip with 1066fsb (not the 667fsb of mobile chips) and with ddr2 800 does 21secs super pi 1m... although at 3ghz it does 17 secs... and 4ghz it does 12.609 :beer:


go with a intel c2d lappy
just wait these are going to be fast if they do come out

Rumored to use this socket:

* Core 2 Duo X7800 (2.6 GHz)
* Core 2 Duo X7900 (2.8 GHz)
 
Evilsizer said:
this is only true if the laptop has a yohan based cpu and he upgrades to the meron.
the new socket P cpu's are not the same to 479, as i recall they are going to be pinless like lga but not the same layout.


http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=3180
http://news.softpedia.com/news/Deta...pcoming-Socket-P-Mobile-Processor-29166.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socket_P

as you can see here the socket P cpus are listed on intel's site.
http://processorfinder.intel.com/List.aspx?ProcFam=2643&sSpec=&OrdCode=
now we just wait for them to show up in lappies.

*edit*
ok so they still are using pins... maybe its the next gen then...

Well yeah, I'm aware of all that. I was just talking about what's currently available. I intend to personally upgrade to C2D sometime in the near future. And if he gets a good deal on a slower memron now, he'll be able to upgrade to a faster memron later if need be. I'm not sure if he'll have that option with socket P.
 
GigaHertzAddict said:
Bottom line... Don't even look at AMD... go with intel on a Laptop... Even if you get a cheap intel laptop, it will destroy a highend AMD laptop.


qft.... amd looks pretty skrewed right now... i really wanna know how they are gonna dig them selves out... i mean not only do they have the c2d to deal with as it is just straight up pwning anything they have to offer... they have to deal with their flop of a HD2900XT gfx card that was said to be 2x as good as a 8800gtx... and its barly as good as a 8800gts 320mb...
 
Back