• Welcome to Overclockers Forums! Join us to reply in threads, receive reduced ads, and to customize your site experience!

best hard drive?

Overclockers is supported by our readers. When you click a link to make a purchase, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

Satai

Registered
Joined
Nov 14, 2003
i have seen a lot of threads and posts with people complaining their hard drives have bit the dust. what is the best hard drive out there these days. i'm building my first computer and don't want to make a stupid mistake. thankyou for awnsering a newbies question.
 
Welcome to the Forums Satai.

The Western Digital 8MB cache models at NewEgg show they come with a 3 year warranty... better than the 1 year warranty that seems to come with most hard drives.
 
I would go with either the WD or maybe a maxtor. As said above the WD has the better warranty and they are good drives. With any drive you get you are taking a chance with a failure, but that is where the 3 year warranty is comes in.

Good Luck
 
in terms of performance, the Hitachi/IBM 7K250 is the fastest 7200rpm drive right now.

shiyan said:
I own 3 WD1200JBs and they are great.

However, I am pretty convinced that the Hitachi/IBM 7K250 is the fastest in the 7200rpm category.

here's a comparison of the top 7200rpm drives from the manufacturers you mentioned:
http://www.storagereview.com/php/be...&devID_2=245&devID_3=252&devID_4=242&devCnt=5

here's a mini review done by larva, in which he compares the 80GB WD SE with the 7K250: http://forum.oc-forums.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=237664

In terms of reliability, Seagate is best. Seagate make the most reliable hard drives, but they are slow.

shiyan said:
to cut the chase, this is what you see in the last article I link to:

"Seagate ... fail rate 1,3%, Maxtor (2,2%). Western Digital (2,4%) and IBM (3,3%)." (this comes from data on more than 1 million drives combined) http://www.tweakers.net/nieuws/29281

these are the failure rates seen by a large online shop in France, with large numbers of drives sold, so those results are pretty reliable.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

first of all, a really nice place to look at reliability accounts from a personal perspective from different people is the storagereview reliability survey/database.

you need to register though.

I had a look, and seagate does seem to have some very reliable drives, Barracuda ATA 3, 4, 5 all were around 90% more reliable than other drives.

for more objective results, I've found these reports:
(french) http://www.hardware.fr/news/lire/22-05-2002/#4844
this was in May 2003, and reposted in a table here:
(dutch)http://www.tweakers.net/nieuws/24556
"Gemiddeld" means average. "mei" is just May.

and most recently:
(dutch)http://www.tweakers.net/nieuws/29281
most notable was that the 200GB Maxtor had a spectacularly high failure rate of 8.8%, and the 60GB 180GXP had a pretty awful 7,03%.

these results all come from LDLC, one of the largest online shops in France.
 
1Time said:
Welcome to the Forums Satai.

The Western Digital 8MB cache models at NewEgg show they come with a 3 year warranty... better than the 1 year warranty that seems to come with most hard drives.

i was planning on getting the WD 120GB from newegg and i saw the 3 year warrenty, however at the time i did not know wether that warrenty was pretty much universal for Hard Drive manufacturers. thanks for the advice. now i'm not just stumbling around in the dark here. and thanks for the welcome.
 
Thankyou Yog and shiyan for your input. i will look into the hard drives that you recommended.
 
As with anything, it depends on what you're looking for.

Seagate are very quiet, and are reliable, but not the fastest.

WD is what I usually go with. The Raptors are the fastest IDE drives on the market right now (SATA, 10,000 rpm, 8mb cache), with a 5 year warranty(!), but they're small (36 gig) and expensive for their size. There are other WD drives out right now that are larger and not as costly, but not quite as fast and with a 3 year warranty (which is still pretty good).
 
Back