Alea iacta est.
Last night I was sure I was going to settle for getting the M5A99X EVO for $70, and this morning Geeks cut the price of the Sabertooth's to $99 so I went ahead and splurged a bit on it. I think my main aversion to going for a Sabertooth was just the name. I have had a long standing policy of trying to avoid dealing with companies or products named after venomous or vicious creatures or anything evil or criminal in nature. For example, I can guarantee you that I will never buy a "Diablotech" product. In my experience people consciously or sub-consciously choose names to represent their base nature. I am guessing the "Sabertooth" name was meant to sound tough instead of hostile or archaic. In my opinion the marketing guys that came up with using something relating to a vicious ancient beast as a name for a high-tech product should be given the boot, but that's just me.
I figured I would follow up on my Geeks experience in this thread for future reference, I will post the results of my second try with getting a refurbished mobo from Geeks. The first try was obviously a swing and a miss, hopefully this was just a fluke and they make good on their refund of the trash CHV they sent me.