- Joined
- Sep 17, 2001
- Location
- Nothingness is Everything.
- Thread Starter
- #21
Usually the easiest way to troubleshoot a faulty component is with spare parts, swapping parts in and out until the problem component has been isolated. Without that, it's just guessing, although those of us with years of experience doing this can usually make an educated guess based on our past experiences.
I think that's why some people get upset when there's a CPU socket change, video card slot change, RAM standard change, etc, because we know we might need spares to troubleshoot new builds.
It doesn't happen often, but I have seen situations where a particular motherboard and power supply combination just won't work reliably for whatever reason and changing one or the other results in perfectly normal operation. It's just one of those things. Problems can range from not powering up, powering up but failing to POST, powering off unexpectedly, and of course, the problem you describe, intermittent operation.
Have you tried removing the motherboard from the case, installing the minimum needed to operate the PC (CPU RAM VIDEO KB) to see if the problem goes away? This removes the possibility of a case short, and reduces the load to minimum.
I agree totally on the component swapping....unfortunately all my spare components have been cleared out in recent years with all the new formats. Sorry AGP graphics card, sorry SDRAM, etc.
I have definitely tried it with nothing but minimum components required for operation but I haven't removed it from the case. I can't imagine that would be a case short only because as I said, if the CMOS jumper is closed, and the battery is out, it powers on and stays on. It also can't be shut off other than via the PSU, but still, I don't think it could physically stay on if it was shorting on something.
I might as well try it when I get home anyways.