Generically speaking, no motherboard company does good all the time doing RMA's. I actually had the opportunity to see the insides of RMA for DFI a number of years ago and there was a lot of stuff going on. So I know there is room for crap to fall into the cracks.
I got the emails that went to the "wherever" place it is that most have to email to start an RMA with a motherboard company. Then I bumped the process to the next step and the boards begin a journey thru a maze before the board ever returns to the customer.
No matter how good or effecient the process was designed to be there were issues. Out of the many RMAs that went thru my hands I only received about 4 attaboys over 6.5 years. The attaboys though came from people that really had their act together and had been thru the RMA system elsewhere and were duly impressed with how DFI had managed their RMA. Thru those 6.5 years, I would have to estimate that 97% of the people were satisfied with the RMA process, but you can be assured that percent that had or felt they had issues voiced it to the heavens. I know because I managed DFI's motherboard forum for the 3.5 years they had it in place.
Personally, I have had only 3 RMA experiences to date. One in particular was with the manufacturer themselves. It was a hard drive company and I had all the testing I could do done and in order before I contacted them. At the first level they wanted to know the usual beginning with who, what and why. Had it covered. Level two sent me to do some more testing. Then level three sent me some tests by email which I did and reported back with. Level three sent me two sets of drives to test and with the original set I bought that is three sets of drives. Enter Level 4 and I had my 2.5 sheets of legal paper with every step they had had me walk thru and so I received a check for the drives and the original shipping and call tags for any other shipping to get the drives back to that particular hard drive manufacturer.
If I remember correctly, I told my wife it took me an actual 26 hours of effort to get the relief I received in the end, which was all my money back. Figured on what I made hourly at the time, I still lost about $110.00 but I felt good. Hehehe. Yeah right. To this day I have never said good or bad about that company. I have told the story about 4 times as you see it written as above. I only had the pretty positive results because I had an idea of how the RMA process works. Dot every I and cross every T and yet we know there are still failures and always will be.
The other two RMA experiences that I have had were handled by NewEgg and they were very positive experiences. But they gave me the shaft on another type situation last year and I now check each purchase I make to see if I can get a comparable price elsewhere. That one shafting without excuse has left that taste in my mouth. I must admit though that in that shafting situation, I never took it to level 2 or 3 which if I had done so, might well have had a good outcome, but I did not. I guess my bad to date.
So there is every sort of bad or less than stellar RMA situation out there. I suspect it is the nature of the beast. We just never hear of the ones that seem good. The actual end result is almost always dependent on the levels of BS we are willing to go upward through to reach a more satisfactory outcome. Then it becomes a case of is it worth it? In "trents" case there was a humongous dropping of the ball for sure.
RGone...