Which is better

Hello, I was wondering, which is a better cooling solution, the Thermaltake Extreme Giant lll, or the VGA Silencer? I hear people getting higher clock speeds with the VGA Silencer over the Giant lll? What do you guys think?

Thermaltake Extreme Giant 3:http://www.xoxide.com/giantiii.html
VGA Silencer:http://www.xoxide.com/vgasilencer.html
Sorry about that, wrong link, this is the revision 2, not 3. I mean, which is better, revision 3 or giant 3?

I have a Thermaltake Giant lll and my MAX clock speeds without graphical errors is around 446/764.

Cmon, is anybody out there? I know somebody knows.....

For my 9700 pro, I was having a thermaltake giant 2, and changed it for a silencer rev 3.

No change at all for the overclock, so if you already have the giant 3, keep it, BUT if not take the vga silencer, because much much easier to install, put the hot air outside, and is cheaper.