I am having trouble seeing how it is retarded to compare to different MMOs. A good portion of what our opinion is formed off of comparisons. Comparisons let us see what a new game brings to the table and where it is lacking. Comparisons allow explaining a game to someone in terms of something they are familiar with. MMOs are at least a good portion of them operate on a WoW like mechanics, Wow did not start these mechanics though. MMOs all build off of innovations in other MMOs, this is what allows us to compare Aion to AoC to Everquest to WoW.
The problem is, when people like CaRpENoCTeM screw up, and use the wrong damn word, it causes this exact problem. ( And I did this myself too in a different thread. So I had also screwed up, and used the wrong words, which caused someone to reply to me in the same way you replied to CaRpENoCTeM. )
There is 100% no problem in comparing two different games. The problem is, when someone claims that a game is a knock-off of another game. Instead of "compare / comparison", he should have said "It's BS to claim AION is a rip-off / knock-off of WoW".
I've told many people, and said it here in these forums. AION is basically an upgraded, slightly more western version of Lineage / Lineage 2. It's not a WoW rip-off, or WoW clone.
Seriously, If we used that logic, then WoW is a rip-off of Everquest. So, why the hell are WoW players playing a KNOCK-OFF, when they should be playing the ORIGINAL. ( See how stupid that sounds. )
But I agree with what you say. Comparing two games is the norm. And comparing Aion to WoW is perfectly fine. And yes, WoW didn't innovate most of the MMO mechanics. It just built on top of what was already out.
Hell, I compare almost all MMO's I play to Eve-Online. Eve is probably the most different MMO out there at the moment. It's VASTLY different than the typical MMO. But it still has a few things in common. And it does many things right ( I'm in love with the Eve-Market. No other MMO has a market that can hold a candle to what eve has made...In my opinion ).
Aion is fun. The grind is getting worse. But I love crafting, So it helps when I'm tired of grinding. That, and I watch Movies / TV shows while playing. so the grind isn't bad at all. Just time consuming.