- Joined
- May 29, 2005
With the current console generation winding down and the Playstation 4 and Xbox One consoles coming out in the middle of November (as well as the Wii U already having been out for about a year), I thought we could come together and vote/discuss what games we found were the best of this past video game generation.
I anticipate the list to include but is not limited to: PC, 360, PS3, Wii, and Mobile/Handheld games.
As always there are some caveats to this discussion:
So general rules for a submission:
Hopefully if this thread is popular enough we can publish a list of the top10 (ish) "best games of the 2005-2013 gaming generation" by the end of the year! I'll do my best to keep a tally/running list and maybe break it down by system if needed or at least mark it for how it can be played.
[oldtable]Game | Votes
Assassins Creed II | 2
World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade | 5
Portal | 6
Super Mario Galaxy 2 | 2
Mass Effect 2 | 4
Left 4 Dead 2 | 2
Fallout 3 | 3
Medal of Honor | 1
DayZ | 1
Crysis | 4
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | 6
League of Legends | 1
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim | 2
Portal 2 | 2
Day of Defeat: Source | 1
Saints Row 3 | 1
Far Cry | 1
Just Cause 2 | 1
Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 | 1
Forza 4 | 1
Dirt 2 | 2
Starcraft 2 | 4
Duke Nukem Forever | 1
Bulletstorm | 1
Battlefield 3 | 2
Borderlands | 2
Wii Sports | 1
Team Fortress 2 | 1
Eve Online | 1
Final Fantasy X3 | 1
The Witcher 2 | 1
World of Warcraft: [EU Vanilla Release] | 1
Ultima Online: Kingdom Reborn | 1
Xcom: Enemy Unknown | 1
Tomb Raider | 1
Super Smash Bros Brawl | 1
Far Cry 3 | 1
Batman: Arkham City | 1
Red Dead Redemption | 1
Assassins Creed: Brotherhood | 1
Castlevania: Lords of Shadows | 1
Torchlight 2 | 1
Dark Souls | 1
God of War 3 | 1
The Last of Us | 1
Rainbow 6: Vegas | 1
Battlefield: Bad Company 2 | 1
Borderlands 2 | 1
Age of Empires III | 1
NHL 11 | 1
Call of Duty: World at War | 1
World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King | 1
Halo 3 | 1
Diablo III | 1
[/table]
I anticipate the list to include but is not limited to: PC, 360, PS3, Wii, and Mobile/Handheld games.
As always there are some caveats to this discussion:
- PC Games don't directly have a 'generation', so we will need to use a cut-off year. For the purpose of this poll I figure we should begin in 2005 - the year the first of the current generation of consoles (Xbox 360) launched.
- There were many series/sequels to come out during this cycle. For that reason I would request only a single game of a series/trilogy be picked per person, as I'm willing to bet one stands out above the others in your minds.
- Opinions of what makes a game great can be very subjective. The game does not need to create a new genre or do something entirely new, but instead may perfect a formula or may simply provide a very short but memorable experience. The games also may not have sold millions of copies but can still be a critics/fan choice.
So general rules for a submission:
- Limited to 5 votes per person
- You don't have to number them best to worst
- Feel free to put a system next to them (or can put cross platform if they are available on multiple)
- Please feel free to post a brief reason of why you think any or each game belongs in the list.
- Lastly, and most importantly, this thread is not meant to start a flame war or heated arguments. This is here to discuss the merits of the fantastic games we have played over the past 9 (2005-2013) years.
Hopefully if this thread is popular enough we can publish a list of the top10 (ish) "best games of the 2005-2013 gaming generation" by the end of the year! I'll do my best to keep a tally/running list and maybe break it down by system if needed or at least mark it for how it can be played.
[oldtable]Game | Votes
Assassins Creed II | 2
World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade | 5
Portal | 6
Super Mario Galaxy 2 | 2
Mass Effect 2 | 4
Left 4 Dead 2 | 2
Fallout 3 | 3
Medal of Honor | 1
DayZ | 1
Crysis | 4
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | 6
League of Legends | 1
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim | 2
Portal 2 | 2
Day of Defeat: Source | 1
Saints Row 3 | 1
Far Cry | 1
Just Cause 2 | 1
Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 | 1
Forza 4 | 1
Dirt 2 | 2
Starcraft 2 | 4
Duke Nukem Forever | 1
Bulletstorm | 1
Battlefield 3 | 2
Borderlands | 2
Wii Sports | 1
Team Fortress 2 | 1
Eve Online | 1
Final Fantasy X3 | 1
The Witcher 2 | 1
World of Warcraft: [EU Vanilla Release] | 1
Ultima Online: Kingdom Reborn | 1
Xcom: Enemy Unknown | 1
Tomb Raider | 1
Super Smash Bros Brawl | 1
Far Cry 3 | 1
Batman: Arkham City | 1
Red Dead Redemption | 1
Assassins Creed: Brotherhood | 1
Castlevania: Lords of Shadows | 1
Torchlight 2 | 1
Dark Souls | 1
God of War 3 | 1
The Last of Us | 1
Rainbow 6: Vegas | 1
Battlefield: Bad Company 2 | 1
Borderlands 2 | 1
Age of Empires III | 1
NHL 11 | 1
Call of Duty: World at War | 1
World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King | 1
Halo 3 | 1
Diablo III | 1
[/table]
Last edited: