I've got a couple XFX 8800GT 256MB cards that just refuse to run any GROGPU2-MT work... immediate EUEs. However, I just tried cranking them back up today and they will run
most standard GROGPU2 units... even some of the p10101 variety.
The cards just seem to be a lost cause when it comes to Folding with any true stability. However, they seem to run general graphics just fine (less stressful I imagine). Probably, as you say, the memory has taken a dump.