Good fans with reasonable temp range – Joe
SUMMARY: Nice set of temperature controlled fans with a “usable” temp range.
Temperature controlled fans are being used more and more as consumers attempt to moderate noise and heat. If a PC is at idle and not throwing off a lot of heat, it makes senses to tie fan rpms to heat – low heat, low rpms, high heat, high rpms. The problem I have noticed on some units is that the temperature range is too wide – I’ve seen it as wide as 25 – 75 C.
Ranges this wide are usually (should be?) outside of what I would consider useful. If you have temps around 75 C, things are too hot to begin with! The Vantec fans feature a range of 25 – 50 C, I think better for PC use.
The thermistor which controls temps is located in each fan’s hub on the exhaust side. If you’re adventurous, cutting the thermistor off and soldering extension wires could be interesting.
To test the fans, I built a “hot-box”:
I took a cardboard box (fittingly, one from Vantec), cut a hole for the fan in one side and a hole to poke a hairdryer in the other. I measured temps at the fan’s exit and recorded cfms with a digital tachometer, removing the hairdryer each time so rpms were not impacted by the blast from the hairdryer.
RPM @ Temp
RPM @ Temp
Fan Specs 25C-50C
|60 x 25 mm|
1827 @ 21.2 C
4250 @ 50 C
1900 – 4200 rpm, 10 – 24 cfm
|80 x 25 mm|
1640 @ 22.2 C
3302 @ 50 C
1950 – 3400 rpm, 24 – 42 cfm
|92 x 25 mm|
1648 @ 22.3 C
2880 @ 50 C
1850 – 3100 rpm, 35 – 58 cfm
The Vantec ThermoFlow Temperature Controlled Fans delivered pretty much as specified. If you’re looking to moderate fan noise (good ones for a power supply), the Vantec’s relatively narrow temp range (25 – 50 C) are worth a look.
Thanks again to Vantec for sending these our way.